A working landmark faces an uncertain future

La Paloma Theater’s value to Encinitas is more than architectural: it remains a working venue where local history and surf culture meet. Reports of a possible sale and conversion into a church and community center have prompted residents and surfers to press for its preservation, though the plans haven’t been publicly confirmed. That uncertainty matters: the community is responding to a reported possibility, not a settled change in ownership or use.

La Paloma’s significance comes partly from what happens inside it. A historic building can be preserved as a physical object, but a venue earns a different kind of attachment through repeated use: screenings, performances and gatherings that make it part of people’s routines and memories. If you're working in this space, that distinction is central to the debate over what preservation should mean.

Why surf culture is part of the story

The theater is the main venue for Taylor Steele’s Sessions Surf Festival and hosted premieres of his Momentum Generation films in the 1990s. For surfers and filmmakers, screening a film at La Paloma has become a coveted rite of passage. The venue gives those events a shared physical setting, connecting current audiences with a history that stretches across generations of surf filmmaking.

Losing that setting would remove a distinctive gathering place from Encinitas and a landmark from surf culture. The impact wouldn’t be limited to the loss of a screen: festivals and premieres depend on the atmosphere of a particular room, the presence of an audience and the chance for people to meet around the work. A replacement venue might host screenings, but it couldn’t automatically carry La Paloma’s accumulated meaning. This is more significant than it looks.

View this post on Instagram

A preservation case already exists

There’s a concrete basis for seeking protection. In 2016, Dudek prepared an 83-page Historical Resource Evaluation Report for Encinitas 101 MainStreet. The report concluded that La Paloma qualifies for historic designation on both the National Register of Historic Places and the California Historical Landmarks registry.

That finding gives preservation advocates a documented starting point, though it doesn’t by itself determine what happens next. A historical evaluation can describe a building’s significance and support a case for recognition; community leaders still have to decide how to use that work as they weigh the theater’s future. The distinction matters because an assessment is evidence for a conversation, not a substitute for one.

Don Miralle, a longtime Encinitas resident and photographer, argues the city should act on the finding and nominate the theater for state and national recognition. Such designation could give preservation efforts a formal footing and make the existing evaluation relevant to public discussion. The question now is whether the city will take up that path while the reported sale and conversion remain unconfirmed.

What residents are asking for

A petition describes La Paloma as a nearly century-old gathering place for film, live performances and community events. It calls for local leaders to explore options that meet community needs while keeping the theater’s historic character and cultural role intact, with preservationists, historians and residents involved in the discussion. That request frames preservation as a process of weighing public use and historic character together, rather than treating the building’s future as a purely architectural question.

The petition asks people to raise awareness and sign in support; it explicitly says donations aren’t being sought at this stage. Its case rests on a simple idea: the venue’s value comes from continued use, from premieres and concerts to the everyday memories made inside it. That said, keeping a venue active takes decisions about who can use it and for what, so the public discussion will need to address practical needs alongside the symbolic case for preservation.

And this is the part most people overlook: a building’s cultural value is easiest to see when it’s still being used. La Paloma’s future will depend on whether Encinitas can turn the evaluation and community interest into a workable discussion about the site. The next step is for the city to determine whether the existing historical evaluation can guide a lasting future for La Paloma.

What happens next

For now, the central facts are limited: a possible sale and conversion have been reported, the plans haven’t been publicly confirmed, and residents are asking city leaders to consider preservation. No outcome is established by the petition or the 2016 evaluation alone. The building’s next chapter remains unsettled.

Read and sign the petition to preserve La Paloma Theater.