(Photo by Luke Hales/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Ohio State’s playoff position now depends on questions that once seemed academic: Can its backup quarterback run a functional passing game, and can the offense find yards when Jeremiah Smith isn’t the answer? The Buckeyes have spent every season since the College Football Playoff rankings began in 2014 inside the top seven. After a second loss, that history offers little comfort. A third defeat would leave them needing help, and four challenging games remain.

The urgency sharpened in Saturday night’s loss to USC. Freshman tight end Mark Bowman turned a catch into a 70-yard gain by hurdling Ohio State safety Jaylen McClain. The play captured a game in which the Buckeyes couldn’t reliably control the action. USC scored 30 points, but the defense has generally held up its end of the bargain. The larger concern is an offense that has lost its starting quarterback and still hasn’t resolved its problems on the ground.

Ohio State might still reach the 12-team playoff with three losses. Parity in the Big Ten and SEC could leave room for one or more three-loss teams. But another defeat would put the Buckeyes’ fate in other teams’ hands. Two more would make their position considerably worse. An 8-4 finish, unthinkable for a team with national championship ambitions, is now within the range of outcomes.

At the end of September, Ohio State looked to me like the most reliably elite team in the country. That judgment assumed the offense would work through its early problems as October began. Instead, those problems have persisted, and the team’s weaknesses now look more consequential with quarterback Julian Sayin injured.

The backup quarterback question

Ohio State entered the season with second-year quarterback Tavien St. Clair as the expected next man in line. At 6-foot-5 and 235 pounds, the former five-star recruit has the size and mobility to offer a different look. He spent 2025 behind Sayin, and as recently as spring, Ohio State reporters believed St. Clair had won the No. 2 job and could become the program’s next standout quarterback.

Ryan Day’s choice tells a different story. True freshman Luke Fahey, a four-star prospect with a lower recruiting rating, beat St. Clair for the backup role. Day hasn’t turned to St. Clair even for specialized packages, despite short-yardage situations against USC that seemed suited to a quarterback with his frame and running ability. That decision suggests Ohio State’s coaches don’t yet trust him to help the offense.

Fahey may develop into a capable quarterback, but his USC performance showed how much work remains. He completed 10 passes to Smith for 83 yards, while his other teammates combined for 11 receptions. He added little as a runner and missed open receivers with several off-target throws, including passes that could have become touchdowns. On a two-point conversion attempt that could have kept Ohio State’s hopes alive, Fahey sent the ball well beyond his target.

There’s no easy solution when a starter goes down. The transfer portal makes it harder to keep experienced quarterbacks waiting behind a top player, even for a program with a reported $50 million roster. But with Sayin’s return uncertain, Ohio State’s depth chart has become a central part of the playoff equation. If Fahey remains the starter, the offense needs a way to give him easier throws and avoid asking him to win games through the air.

A ground game that hasn’t developed

The run game was already a concern in September. At that point, Ohio State ranked 38th nationally in yards per carry when games against Texas were excluded. The early numbers seemed explainable by a small sample, and Smith’s presence offered a compelling reason to expect the offense to improve. The Buckeyes had found a way to build a late-season rushing attack before.

In 2024, Ohio State averaged 3.9 yards per carry in October, then increased that mark to 4.4 in November and 4.9 in December and January. Quinshon Judkins and TreVeyon Henderson became two of the country’s most productive backs, and the Buckeyes ran for 214 yards on 41 carries against Notre Dame in the national championship game.

That kind of progression hasn’t appeared this season. Ohio State ranks 90th in yards per carry, or 94th when sacks are excluded from the calculation. Its ground attack has looked good in only a couple of Big Ten games, against Illinois and Maryland, and has struggled against the defensive fronts of Texas, Indiana and Iowa. USC, despite its broader defensive problems, also contained much of the damage from running back Bo Jackson.

Jackson finished with 121 yards on 21 carries, but Ohio State’s runs rarely threatened to flip the field. The team has managed only three carries of at least 20 yards since Week 1, one in each of its last three games. Against Power 4 opponents, its three such runs tie for 53rd among 67 teams and Notre Dame. Without explosive runs, the offense has fewer ways to reduce pressure on its quarterback.

The passing game has produced big plays, but most of that work belongs to Smith. Receivers other than Smith have combined for just 15 catches of 20 or more yards, a total that would rank 54th among power-conference teams. Smith can remain productive against focused coverage, but USC showed the cost of forcing him to carry too much: no other Buckeye caught more than two passes.

Four difficult chances to slip

Ohio State’s remaining schedule doesn’t include a great team, but it does include four opponents capable of making the game uncomfortable. That’s a risky setup for an offense struggling to run consistently and still searching for stability at quarterback.

  • Oregon has endured a poor season, yet it has held five of its eight opponents below 4.3 yards per carry when sacks are excluded. The Ducks also have future NFL talent along the defensive line and enough skill-position ability to challenge Ohio State. A comfortable win isn’t a safe assumption.
  • Northwestern has Chip Kelly calling plays, and its offense could present a problem if the game turns into a shootout. The Wildcats’ rush defense is weak, which gives Ohio State a possible route to control the matchup. But if Sayin can’t play, the quarterback comparison becomes less reassuring for the Buckeyes.
  • Nebraska brings a strong defensive front and the advantage of playing at home in Lincoln. Ohio State may have trouble running against that group. The Huskers still have to show they can beat a ranked opponent, but their defense is equipped to make this a close game.
  • Michigan has the country’s best defense, according to the source analysis, and Ohio State will have to contend with a formidable front. Michigan’s season has been hampered by its own weak offense, but the defensive matchup could still evoke Ohio State’s 2024 loss to a similar Michigan team in the Horseshoe.

The Buckeyes should be favored in all four games, but each offers a plausible path to a close finish. That leaves little room for a slow start, missed throws or another stalled rushing performance. Ohio State’s defense can keep it competitive, and Smith can still change a game. The playoff question now turns on whether the rest of the offense can contribute enough before the schedule runs out.

A third loss would put the Buckeyes in a position where selection-day calculations matter. Two more would likely end their playoff hopes. For a program accustomed to living near the top of the rankings, the immediate task is more basic: make the backup quarterback’s job manageable, find a reliable ground game and turn four difficult matchups into wins.