(Photo by Chris Leduc/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images) | Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

Florida State’s next coach will inherit a program with a recent high point and a sharp fall from it. Mike Norvell is out after a 36-24 loss to Clemson, ending a tenure that included a 13-1 season in 2023 but also two losing seasons since. The next hire needs to restore consistency while giving the Seminoles a clear path back into contention.

The candidate pool ranges from established conference winners to coaches who would represent a substantial bet on potential. Familiarity with Florida State and the ACC could help narrow the search, but each name carries a different question: whether the coach would leave a strong program, whether past results will hold up at a larger job, or whether the step up comes too soon.

Manny Diaz has the clearest case

Duke head coach Manny Diaz sits at the top of this group because his résumé connects the job’s regional and competitive demands. He attended Florida State, graduating with a communications degree in 1995, and began his coaching career as a graduate assistant under Bobby Bowden. Since then, his stops have included NC State, Texas, Mississippi State, Miami and Penn State. His first head coaching job came at Miami.

His strongest results have come at Duke. Diaz guided the Blue Devils to nine wins in both 2024 and 2025, and Duke captured the ACC Championship Game a year ago. That combination matters: he knows the conference, has coached in Florida, and has recently shown he can build a winning team inside the ACC. Florida State would still be a different scale of challenge, but Diaz looks like the most direct fit among the names being considered.

Jake Dickert brings momentum from Wake Forest

Wake Forest’s Jake Dickert is another candidate whose recent results should draw attention. The Demon Deacons went 9-4 a year ago and are 7-1 this season, ranked in the top 15. Dickert also had a winning record at Washington State, finishing 23-20, and has gone 16-5 through two years at Wake Forest.

His work with general manager Rob Schlaeger is part of the appeal. Their approach to evaluating talent and bringing players to campus could translate well within the ACC. On paper, Dickert may be the strongest option after Diaz, though Florida State would need to decide whether his program-building record outweighs Diaz’s deeper ties to the Seminoles and his recent conference title.

Missouri’s Eliah Drinkwitz offers proven SEC results

Eliah Drinkwitz has made Missouri a consistent bowl team, reaching one in every season of his tenure. The Tigers won 11 games in 2023 and 10 in 2024, and are on pace for another double-digit-win season. Those results give Drinkwitz a substantial body of work against SEC competition.

The open question is whether he sees Florida State as a better platform for his next step. Missouri has become an intriguing program, but the SEC includes major powers such as Alabama and LSU. Tallahassee could offer a different route to the top tier of the sport, while also bringing its own pressure and recent instability. Drinkwitz would be a proven hire, though his willingness to leave Columbia is far from certain.

Glenn Schumann would mark a change in direction

Georgia defensive coordinator Glenn Schumann would offer a different profile from Florida State’s historical preference for offensive-minded head coaches. The program’s last hire with a purely defensive background was Larry Jones, a former South Carolina defensive coordinator hired in 1971.

Schumann has been discussed for head coaching openings in recent cycles. Kirby Smart supported him for the North Carolina job in 2024, before the school hired Bill Belichick. Schumann’s experience working under Smart and Nick Saban gives him a strong coaching lineage, and this could be the point when he moves into a head job. The uncertainty is straightforward: coordinating at Georgia is not the same as running a major program.

Rhett Lashlee would be a difficult poach

SMU head coach Rhett Lashlee has built a strong position in Dallas. The Mustangs have gone 44-17 under his leadership, including a 30-6 conference record, and have reached a bowl game every season of his tenure. At 6-1 this year, SMU appears headed for another bowl and could contend for a second College Football Playoff appearance under Lashlee.

Florida State might like the idea of hiring a successful coach from an ACC rival, but Lashlee would have good reason to stay. He has institutional support and resources at SMU, and his team is already winning in the same conference. For the Seminoles, he is an attractive target; for Lashlee, Tallahassee could look like a riskier situation than the one he has built.

Kenny Dillingham knows the Seminoles’ environment

Arizona State’s Kenny Dillingham has experience at Florida State, where he worked under Norvell, and that familiarity could help him understand the job’s demands. His coaching résumé also includes Auburn and Oregon, while Arizona State reached the College Football Playoff in 2024.

The connection to Norvell complicates the fit. Dillingham is in a good position at Arizona State, and his ties to the outgoing coach could make a move less appealing. Still, he knows the program and has experience in several major college settings. Those are useful qualifications for a candidate who would be asked to take on a high-pressure rebuild.

Zach Kittley is the high-upside in-state option

Florida Atlantic’s Zach Kittley has only recently become a head coach, taking over in 2025. The Owls went 4-8 in his first season, but are on course for a winning record and bowl bid in 2026. A Florida State hire would be a major leap based on that short head coaching record.

Kittley’s offensive background is the reason to consider it. He coached quarterback Bailey Zappe at Houston Baptist, where he served as offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach, and later at Western Kentucky. Zappe set several NCAA records during that stretch. If Florida State prioritizes offensive identity and quarterback development, Kittley offers a promising profile, though the scale of the job would make him a bold choice.

Jimbo Fisher and Deion Sanders bring different kinds of risk

Jimbo Fisher has already delivered a national title at Florida State, along with five consecutive 10-win seasons and three conference championships. He has said he wants to return to coaching, making a reunion easy to imagine. Yet his departure from Tallahassee may have left hard feelings, and his time at Texas A&M could weigh against bringing him back. A previous championship makes the case; the circumstances around his exit and later tenure complicate it.

Colorado’s Deion Sanders offers a more dramatic story. He was a three-sport star at Florida State, excelling in football as well as baseball and track. In May 1987, Sanders played in two conference tournament baseball games and ran a leg of the 4 x 100 relay on the same day. A return to campus would carry real personal resonance.

His recent coaching results make the football case less certain. Colorado went 9-4 in 2024, when Sanders coached Heisman Trophy winner Travis Hunter Jr., then fell to 3-9 in 2025 and is on pace for another losing season this year. The reunion has an appealing storyline, but Florida State would be taking on a coach whose latest results have cooled.

Florida State’s choice will reveal its priorities

The leading options present a choice between immediate conference credibility and a longer-term bet on fit or potential. Diaz and Dickert have recent ACC success; Drinkwitz and Lashlee bring substantial winning records; Schumann and Kittley would be less tested as program leaders. Fisher and Sanders offer name recognition and history, alongside questions raised by their recent or past circumstances.

For Florida State, the most persuasive hire will be the one whose record matches the program’s most urgent needs. Diaz currently has the strongest blend of Seminole ties, Florida experience and ACC results. The final decision will show whether the school values that direct connection or sees a stronger path in another coach’s trajectory.