A free-agent forecast with unusually wide error bars

Ben Clemens opened the chat by saying he’d try to give fuller answers about each player, while grouping or skipping questions that overlapped. The exchange quickly got to the point of his free-agent rankings: this year’s list is unusually hard to trust. Clemens said the combination of a divisive new collective bargaining agreement and what he called the weakest free-agent class of his time as a baseball writer made the forecasts especially difficult. He expects this group to receive less total money than last year’s for the first time since he began making these projections, though he sees slightly more spending per projected win. He also said he’d never been less confident in a list, despite putting substantial work into it. That uncertainty shows up in his contract assumptions. Clemens is generally projecting shorter deals, and acknowledged that contract length is the weakest part of his approach: he compares possible deals of different lengths and uses his judgment to decide what seems plausible. For the top free agents, that’s a real challenge in a market where short deals and high average annual values have become more common. He thinks a repeat of last year’s eye-catching contracts for players such as Tucker and Bichette is possible, but more likely to take the form of short-term deals with high annual salaries. Even so, he considers a repeat unlikely: this class has only four or five exciting free agents at the top, and is thinner than last year’s group. He expects the middle of the rankings to see brisk business, in part because teams may want to spend before a lockout.

Where Clemens disagrees with the market

Asked where his rankings diverge most from other forecasts, Clemens pointed to Kris Bubic on the high side. He suspects his contract estimate is above what Bubic will actually receive, but said he couldn’t bring himself to project less. Based on the information he has, he’d want Bubic on his team, setting health concerns aside. On the low side, he named Randy Arozarena, whom he doesn’t view as a marquee free agent despite seeing him in the top five of many other lists. He also said he may be low on pitchers Matt Boyd, Brandon Woodruff and Kevin Gausman. The rankings themselves involve plenty of close calls. Clemens said Taira, Sato and Jeffers were among the hardest players to place. Jazz Chisholm was difficult to forecast financially, but Clemens kept him in the top 10 and settled on placing him after Suzuki and before Arozarena. Taira’s role is unclear, and his pitching style has few close comparisons; Clemens said the pitcher’s age and fastball made him want to rank him even higher. Sato posed a different problem. Clemens had been too optimistic about the previous year’s NPB class, yet saw many of the same traits he liked in Murakami. He also thought Murakami had been underpaid and believed his strong performance in Chicago may have shifted how teams view players coming from Japan. Clemens said both Steamer and ZiPS appeared bullish on Sato, with ZiPS projecting him as the second-best player in the class. He sees potential defensive value and perhaps more contact ability, but stressed that the projection carries major uncertainty.

Small ranking gaps, big judgment calls

The list’s bottom edge came down to a crowded group of relievers. Clemens said Emilio Pagán’s opt-out the day before the chat forced him to remove someone from the 50th spot, leaving Paul Blackburn just outside the rankings. He had considered Blackburn for much of the process, but said roughly 20 relievers had similar projections and little separated them. Blackburn’s recent results were notable, including a fourth-place finish in reliever RA9-WAR that season, but Clemens said he saw less of a clear explanation for Blackburn’s success than he did for some of the pitchers who made the list. He also pushed back on treating Luis Arraez and Gleyber Torres as near-equals for 2027. His projected contracts—two years and $38 million for Arraez, two years and $28 million for Torres—are relatively close. But he questioned the assumption that Torres would slug more: from 2024 through 2026, Torres had a .378 slugging percentage over 1,700 plate appearances, compared with Arraez’s .400 over 2,000. The chat also touched on whether Brewers manager Pat Murphy would receive a postseason report card. Clemens said one would appear, explaining that he had skipped both World Series reports while working on the free-agent list; Jon Becker and Dan Szymborski had written the American League and National League reports, respectively. A reader joked about a player being left off the list and accused Clemens of bias; Clemens played along, calling that player overrated and saying another was ranked too low. The opening exchange leaves a clear impression: these projections are estimates made under unusual uncertainty, and Clemens isn’t trying to disguise the judgment calls behind them. For anyone using the list to think about this market, the rankings and contract lengths deserve more skepticism than usual.

Health risk, unusual arms and contract uncertainty

The most consequential unknown in this free agent discussion may be health. Ben Clemens said there’s no public explanation for why the Padres might decline Nick Pivetta’s option. Given Pivetta’s production, a two-year, $32 million deal looks appealing for a No. 2 or 3 starter, and he finished the season looking healthy. But Clemens said the internal view was that if San Diego passes, the medical picture must be alarming enough to leave Pivetta off the projected list. The club’s decision remains a guess from the outside; Pivetta was considered carefully. Taira is a different kind of uncertainty. Clemens likes unusual arm angles and release points when a pitcher can repeat his mechanics, but he couldn’t say whether Taira’s style will work. That unpredictability is part of the appeal: Clemens compared the experience of watching him to the fascination around Murakami this year. Taira is listed at 5-foot-8 and 220 pounds, prompting a comparison to Bartolo Colon. Clemens sees a more unusual profile: a high-velocity four-seam fastball from an exceptionally low release point. He also sees a little of “Miz,” despite Miz being enormous: a fastball that drives the whole approach, secondaries that benefit from its angle, and command that could improve. Eric likes Taira’s splitter, Clemens said, but expects the fastball to be his defining pitch. Sonny Gray presents a contract puzzle of his own. Clemens would pay him $25 million or more for one season, but prefers a structure that pays year by year; he had Gray tied for the second-highest pitching average annual value in his projections. The logic is straightforward: Gray can still pitch, and a contender should want him in its rotation. He could decline sharply, but hasn’t yet. Clemens also doubts Gray would want to remain on a long deal once he stopped pitching well.

Projecting a market clouded by the CBA

Qualifying offers were hard to forecast because the schedule left the list unfinished. Clemens said the projections would have included at least one player accepting a QO if the writers had known who would receive one. The World Series ending in a sweep would, he believed, have left enough time to publish the list. Without that information, including an acceptance prediction felt premature. Last year, he had a clearer sense of the likely QO recipients. Clemens builds free agent projections player by player, then checks them against broader patterns. He trusts his read on the overall market more than his ability to predict the quirks of each individual contract, so aggregate expectations—such as what pitchers generally should earn—help keep the player-level estimates grounded. This year has put that method under unusual strain: uncertainty around the next collective bargaining agreement clouds the market as a whole. That uncertainty also complicates the question of whether this class will earn less than the previous one. Clemens doesn’t simply shave a fixed percentage off every projection if the totals look high. He does, however, pay attention to the aggregate. If you’re trying to forecast a market, the overall spending pattern can be easier to judge than any one player’s eventual deal. Scarcity makes the projections harder still. Asked who might turn a weak free agent class into an unexpectedly rich contract, Clemens picked Arozarena, especially if a team wants a proven slugger and misses out on Suzuki. He doesn’t expect that outcome, though. The market’s lack of alternatives could matter, but Clemens said he can account for scarcity intuitively more easily than he can model it in numbers.

Where the game gets personal

Some of Clemens’s favorite hypothetical fits were Soroka with the Blue Jays, Taira with the Brewers, and Alec Bohm with the Rockies in Coors Field. The last idea came from Cespedes BBQ, and Clemens meant it as a compliment. Emilio Pagan in Colorado also caught his imagination, though he joked that the result might be spectacular for the wrong reasons. He doesn’t plan to write report cards for managers who missed the postseason. Clemens said he isn’t sure how to evaluate them, and much of a manager’s regular-season work is hard to capture in his analysis: keeping players ready, maintaining cohesion, and handling the roster and pitching staff. Asked what he enjoyed in the playoffs, Clemens named Brewers and Rays games, with the Brewers’ run carrying a family connection: his wife is from Milwaukee, and her mother has season tickets. They went to the series; he didn’t. Among individual performances, he singled out Michael King returning on zero days’ rest and Nick Martinez pitching in the World Series. He also enjoyed the Bauers-Frelick-Passan friendship, Pat Murphy teasing Cooper Pratt, and Patrick Bailey pinch-hitting for Austin Hedges. A lighter question turned to lunch. Clemens had a Factor meal kit because he and his household rotate meal services based on deals and their schedule; they’d been busy, and Factor had a good offer. He hoped lunch would get more interesting in the offseason, when he expected to have more free time.

A thin free-agent class puts more weight on the top names

The biggest takeaway from Ben Clemens’s projections is how little depth this free-agent group appears to have. More of the top-end players than usual signed extensions, leaving the middle of the list looking familiar while the overall projections come in lighter than any group he’s assessed before. That’s a meaningful constraint for teams looking to spend. The market for Taira is harder to pin down. Clemens expects him to end up in the bullpen, though a team willing to pay the most may see a real chance he can start. Taira didn’t start often in NPB, but he got a chance to do so this year; a signing team could give him another look before settling on relief. Clemens thinks his style fits the bullpen better over the long haul, while stressing that the uncertainty is unusually high.

Small samples can move a player in both directions

Mize’s performance with the Padres likely hurt his standing, Clemens said. He makes two versions of his list: an early September pass based more on impression, then a playoff-time update that incorporates projections and a deeper statistical look. Mize ranked much higher on the first, “vibes based” version. Clemens says he leaned too heavily on Mize’s first half, giving extra credit to his trajectory, first overall pick pedigree and stuff while discounting earlier struggles. The caveat cuts both ways. Mize’s recent success came over a small sample too; it just feels more convincing when he’s pitching well right now. Kyle Harrison, meanwhile, stayed on Milwaukee’s roster for all three postseason series and never appeared. Clemens says the Brewers had tested him late in the regular season, when he wasn’t looking sharp, but kept him as an upside option in case they ran short on pitching. Their wins and comfortable margins meant they never had to use him. The roster spot was an unusual middle course, and in the end, an unused one.

Payroll rules are still speculation

A question about whether a possible cap and floor might make Milwaukee more likely to bring back Bauers drew a pointed response: Clemens doesn’t accept that such a system is settled. A cap, a floor or a hybrid could emerge, he said, but claims that anyone already knows the final numbers are wishful thinking. He also expects any major change to baseball’s financial rules to arrive gradually. Whether the proposal involves the league’s cap floor or a players’ soft floor paired with TV revenue redistribution, a phase-in would ease the immediate pressure on teams. Without one, the Nationals and Marlins could face a demand to roughly double payroll while the Dodgers would have to cut theirs by two-thirds. That scale of adjustment makes an overnight shift hard to imagine. And on Randy Arozarena, Clemens sees Philadelphia as a plausible destination if asked to make a projection. He likened Arozarena to a next-generation Castellanos in some ways—a comparison that hints at the kind of hitter Philly might pursue, though it doesn’t make the destination any less uncertain.