Ohio State can keep its top-five standing without Julian Sayin, but its game at USC will reveal how much that ranking depends on one quarterback. The Buckeyes have the talent to remain a national title contender. Their ability to protect a new starter may decide whether they look like one on Saturday.

Protection is the immediate problem

Sayin was injured in Ohio State’s Week 7 win over Indiana, after taking four sacks. The Hoosiers repeatedly pressured him, disrupting his timing and making it harder to get the ball to wide receiver Jeremiah Smith. Sayin looked rattled, and the accumulated hits eventually knocked him out of the game with an injury to his throwing arm.

The injury isn’t the only concern. Ohio State’s offensive line has allowed nine sacks across its last two games against Indiana, and it has surrendered at least two sacks to every top-25 opponent it has faced this season. That record gives USC a clear way to test the Buckeyes: pressure the quarterback early and force him to respond.

Sayin’s replacement could be Luke Fahey or former five-star recruit Tavien St. Clair. Either would face a difficult first assignment on the road, against a defense coordinated by College Football Hall of Famer Gary Patterson. A former Power Four head coach described the likely approach to me this way: “I’m putting in [a] quick-game and running the ball as much as I can to help my QB. I know he’s gonna be overwhelmed, and I know they’re gonna light him up like a Christmas tree. Just be smart. That’s all you can ask of the kid.”

A difficult matchup at a critical moment

USC has reason to treat the matchup as urgent. The Trojans are fighting for a place in the College Football Playoff, and Saturday’s game comes just days before the selection committee releases its first top-25 rankings. For USC coach Lincoln Riley, the result could also carry weight at a tense point in the season.

That gives Patterson and the USC defense every incentive to stress Ohio State’s pass protection. Blitzes could put an inexperienced starter under pressure before he settles in, while forcing the Buckeyes to show whether they can make quick throws and keep the ground game moving. Sayin himself had struggled against pressure, so the backup’s ability to handle it is an open question.

Ohio State has faced a similar depth test before. In the 2023 Cotton Bowl, Devin Brown and Lincoln Kienholz combined to complete 10 of 23 passes for 106 yards in a 14-3 loss to Missouri. Receivers Emeka Egbuka and Carnell Tate were available, but the quarterbacks couldn’t get them the ball reliably. Ryan Day’s visible frustration that night underscored how little the surrounding talent mattered without effective quarterback play.

What Ohio State needs to show

Sayin’s last appearance came in the Week 7 win over Indiana, where he looked out of rhythm before leaving the game. Fahey finished the contest, but his limited playing time offered little reassurance about what a full start might bring. St. Clair presents another option, though either quarterback would be making his case under difficult conditions.

Ohio State’s best support for the new starter is a strong running game and cleaner protection. The offensive line needs to give the quarterback time, while the ground attack must help the Buckeyes control the pace. If USC can force obvious passing situations, the pressure on the new starter will rise quickly.

The Buckeyes enter the road game at the LA Memorial Coliseum ranked No. 2, and they should expect to compete for a win. But the ranking also comes with a standard: Ohio State must show that its season isn’t resting on Sayin’s availability. Saturday will test the team’s depth, Day’s quarterback development and an offensive line that has yet to hold up consistently against strong opponents.

If Ohio State can protect its quarterback and sustain the run, its top-five case remains intact. If USC’s pressure exposes the same weaknesses seen against Indiana, the Buckeyes will leave a serious question hanging over their playoff credentials.