The U.S. men’s national team’s Nations League quarterfinal against Haiti calls for a different roster balance than the experimental group that impressed in September and October. Those earlier matches helped the United States beat Mexico, Canada, Chile and Peru, but they carried no standings implications. This two-leg series does: the winner on aggregate advances to March’s final four.
That pressure points Mauricio Pochettino toward experienced players, even as teenagers Julian Hall and Cavan Sullivan make strong cases to stay with the senior team. Many of the other young players are likely to join U.S. under-20 or under-23 camps in Europe. The U-23 group also serves as the early pathway toward the 2028 Olympic team.
The projected roster below weighs club form, availability and the competition’s stakes. Injured players are marked with an asterisk; players eligible for the 2028 Olympics carry two.
Strikers: Balogun’s fitness shapes the choices
Projected: Folarin Balogun, Monaco; Julian Hall, New York Red Bulls; Justin Ellis, Orlando City SC.
Just missed: Ricardo Pepi*, Haji Wright*, Patrick Agyemang*, Zavier Gozo**, Brian White, Milan Iloski*, Preston Judd.
Balogun’s place is a call-up on reputation and need more than recent playing time. A knee problem has restricted the U.S. forward to four substitute appearances for Monaco and just 74 minutes since the summer. Yet Pepi, Wright and Agyemang are unavailable, leaving Pochettino short of established options. With a semifinal berth on the line, Balogun is still the likeliest selection if he’s fit enough to contribute.
That shortage could also bring Hall and Ellis back from youth-team plans. Both would benefit from continued development with Steve Cherundolo’s group, but the senior team may need their attacking options. Hall’s strong recent run includes the September and October camp, when the U.S. beat four opponents.
If the younger forwards stay with their age-group teams, Brian White deserves attention. The 30-year-old Vancouver Whitecaps striker has scored 18 MLS goals and offers a physical style that could suit a matchup with Haiti.
Wingers: Pulisic may return, Sullivan’s ankle is a concern
Projected: Christian Pulisic, AC Milan; Sergiño Dest, PSV Eindhoven; Gio Reyna, Strasbourg; Cavan Sullivan**, Philadelphia Union.
Just missed: Brenden Aaronson, Mathis Albert**, Cole Campbell**, Diego Luna*, Alex Zendejas, Peyton Miller**.
Dest and Reyna look like straightforward selections, given their regular roles at club level. Pulisic’s return is less certain, but the signs point toward a call-up. U.S. assistant coach Jesus Perez watched him come off the bench during AC Milan’s 4-2 loss to Bologna. Pulisic had also scored his second goal of the Italian season the previous weekend, and could be back with the national team for the first time since the World Cup.
Sullivan’s case hinges on his ankle. The 17-year-old earned a recall after his September and October performances, but has missed Philadelphia’s last two matches with soreness. If he’s unavailable, Aaronson offers a senior alternative: the Leeds United midfielder made his first Premier League start in four games last weekend.
Zendejas is another possibility now that he’s healthy. Dortmund teenager Albert, by contrast, has played only 21 Bundesliga minutes this season. He, Campbell and Miller are more likely to join Cherundolo’s side or the U-20s than the senior roster.
Midfield: McKennie is back in the picture
Projected: Tyler Adams, Bournemouth; Weston McKennie, Juventus; Sebastian Berhalter, Middlesbrough; Aidan Morris, Middlesbrough; Yunus Musah, AC Milan; Malik Tillman, Bayer Leverkusen.
Just missed: Johnny Cardoso*, Tanner Tessmann, Adri Mehmeti**, Brooklyn Raines**, Gianluca Busio*.
McKennie’s September omission followed a minor injury, but his club form has made a return likely. He has started all eight Juventus matches since then and played all but one minute across the last five. Berhalter has also become a regular in the national-team picture.
Musah’s season hasn’t been especially convincing, but his minutes at Milan support a selection. He started four of the club’s last five matches and played the full game Wednesday, with Perez watching. Cardoso might otherwise have been in contention after ankle surgery kept him out of the World Cup; a hamstring strain has now sidelined him.
Tessmann is beginning to find his form at Lyon, but Morris has a strong claim after an excellent campaign with Middlesbrough, which is leading the Premier League promotion race. That puts Morris in line for the opening, while Tillman and Adams round out a midfield built for a consequential tie.
Center backs: Trusty’s availability matters
Projected: Chris Richards, Crystal Palace; Mark McKenzie, Toulouse; Auston Trusty, Celtic; Miles Robinson, Cincinnati.
Just missed: Neil Pierre**, George Campbell, Cameron Carter-Vickers.
Richards remains the defensive reference point. He delivered his best performance of the season Wednesday in Crystal Palace’s 1-0 EFL Cup win over Fulham. Trusty has also strengthened his case as the left-footed option following Tim Ream’s retirement. He has featured at center back and left back for the U.S., including in the World Cup defeat to Türkiye—where he scored—and the 1-0 win over Canada on Oct. 6.
Trusty’s absence from Celtic’s last two games followed the death of his father, Walt. His selection may therefore depend on whether he’s ready to return. His performances have given Pochettino a clear reason to include him if he is available.
Fullbacks: Familiar veterans could return
Projected: Antonee “Jedi” Robinson, Fulham; Alex Freeman, Villarreal; Joe Scally, Borussia Mönchengladbach; Tim Weah, Olympique Marseille.
Just missed: Max Arfsten, George Bello, Frankie Westfield**, Luca Bombino**.
Robinson and Freeman look set to start at left and right back. The depth behind them is less settled. Scally and Weah weren’t named in September, but both have been playing regularly for their clubs. Scally has scored three goals, matching his total from the previous three seasons combined, while Marseille captain Weah scored his first goal of the 2026-27 season last weekend.
The stakes make a return for both experienced players plausible. Arfsten is still adjusting to his first Middlesbrough campaign, while Bombino and Westfield appear more likely to join the youth teams.
Goalkeepers: Schwake has the form edge
Projected: Matt Turner, New England Revolution; Matt Freese, New York City FC; Chris Brady, Chicago Fire; Brian Schwake, Nashville SC.
Just missed: Diego Kochen**.
The starting job is the most open question. Freese was the World Cup No. 1 but played only 45 minutes across the U.S.’s last four games. Turner, the starter at Qatar 2022, and newcomer Schwake have both outperformed him in MLS this season.
Kochen could be considered after shutting out Mexico earlier this month, but the 20-year-old is more likely to join the U-23s as a projected Olympic starter. Schwake is the strongest bet after a standout performance against Canada in the Americans’ most recent outing.
The likely shape of the squad
Pochettino’s selection looks likely to mix returning veterans with a small number of young attackers whose club form has earned senior consideration. Injuries could reshape the forward and midfield groups, while Sullivan’s ankle will determine whether one of the most exciting teenagers remains in the picture. Against Haiti, the roster will reveal how much weight the coach puts on recent momentum from the younger group—and how much he trusts experience when a place in March’s final four is at stake.