A potential break in the quarterback streak
The 2027 NFL Draft odds point to a possible break in the quarterback run: Ohio State receiver Jeremiah Smith is the favorite to go first, with Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker close behind. Quarterbacks have been selected No. 1 in four straight drafts, including Fernando Mendoza by the Las Vegas Raiders. A fifth would extend that streak; Smith could instead become the first wide receiver taken first since Keyshawn Johnson in 1996.
The odds put a position question at the center of the early conversation. A team picking first usually weighs its needs against the value of the prospects available, and the market is signaling that Smith’s production may be strong enough to challenge the usual preference for quarterbacks. That’s a meaningful change in the shape of the race, though betting prices are a snapshot of expectations, not a forecast of what teams will do.
Smith’s production is driving the odds
At FanDuel Sportsbook, as of Oct. 29, Smith is listed at +150. His case rests on a season packed with record-level performances. Against Iowa, he caught 11 passes for 206 yards and two touchdowns, becoming Ohio State’s career leader in receptions, receiving yards and receiving touchdowns.
That combination of weekly output and career milestones gives the favorite a case beyond a brief scoring surge. A receiver’s draft argument depends in part on whether his production looks repeatable against varied defenses, and Smith’s results against Iowa and Illinois offer two prominent examples. The figures alone can’t settle how evaluators will weigh the position, but they make his candidacy difficult to dismiss.
Two weeks earlier, Smith set career highs against Illinois with 12 catches, 217 yards and four touchdowns. He became the fourth Big Ten receiver since 2000 to reach 200 receiving yards and four touchdown catches in one game, and the fifth Buckeye to match Ohio State’s single-game receiving touchdown record.
Smith has cleared 150 receiving yards in four of his seven games: 151 against Ball State, 164 against Texas, 217 against Illinois and 206 against Iowa. That matches Ohio State’s single-season mark for games with at least 150 receiving yards, set by David Boston in 1998. Smith is also the only player this season with 200 receiving yards in consecutive games, a feat achieved by just one other player in Big Ten history: Ty Fryfogle in 2020. He’s one touchdown short of Braylon Edwards’ Big Ten career record for receiving touchdowns.
The records make the scale of the season clear, but they also raise a practical question: how much should a draft market reward a receiver’s peak production when the top pick has so often been a quarterback? This is more significant than it looks. Smith’s odds suggest the answer could depend on whether teams see his receiving value as exceptional enough to outweigh the positional pattern.
A leaping fourth-down catch over two Indiana defenders offered another snapshot of Smith’s impact. The play helped shift momentum in a road win for the Buckeyes, adding a defining moment to an already strong statistical résumé. (And this is the part most people overlook.) A memorable catch can shape how a season is remembered, but a single play can’t carry the same weight as a body of production.
Mestemaker’s rise gives the board a new contender
Mestemaker has climbed to +250, putting him second in the odds. His route to the top tier of college quarterbacks was unusual: at Vandegrift High School in Austin, Texas, he backed up at quarterback and earned all-district honors as a punter without starting a varsity game at quarterback.
Now at Oklahoma State, Mestemaker has thrown for 2,326 yards and 20 touchdowns in seven games. Those totals rank second and fourth, respectively, among FBS players. Across his time at North Texas and Oklahoma State since the start of 2025, he leads FBS in passing yards and ranks second in passing touchdowns and yards per attempt, and fourth in passer rating.
His climb gives the oddsboard a challenger whose résumé is built around quarterback production rather than projection alone. The high school background makes the rise striking, but it doesn’t tell us how teams will assess his development or how he’ll perform over a longer stretch. Here's the thing: for a quarterback in the No. 1 conversation, sustained performance matters because the position’s value tends to dominate draft discussions.
Manning’s uneven season has shifted his standing
Arch Manning’s family history makes the No. 1 pick a familiar possibility. His grandfather Archie went second in 1971; his uncles Peyton and Eli were selected first in 1998 and 2004. Arch is now sixth on the oddsboard at +1600, after opening the season as the favorite.
That family history gives the conversation an easy narrative, but the current odds reflect his own season as well as his name. His first season as a collegiate starter brought 3,163 passing yards, 26 touchdowns and seven interceptions, with a 61.4% completion rate. This season, through seven games, he has 1,507 yards, 12 touchdowns and seven interceptions. The turnovers included a pick-six and a late interception that sealed Oklahoma’s win over Texas in the Red River Rivalry.
Manning has also led Texas to notable wins over Ohio State, Tennessee and Ole Miss. Those results keep his upside in view, though his uneven play has weighed on his odds. The current board gives Smith the lead, with Mestemaker’s production making him the clearest challenger and Manning needing more consistent performances to regain ground.
That leaves the race open to change as the season develops. If you're working in this space, the useful signal is the contrast among the three leading cases: Smith has the records and highlight moments, Mestemaker has climbed on passing production, and Manning has both high-profile wins and a recent run of turnovers. The numbers are compelling. The order can still move.
What the odds say about the race ahead
The board captures a moment in a changing season, not a final judgment on the draft. Smith’s position at the top makes the possibility of a receiver going first feel plausible; Mestemaker’s price keeps a quarterback firmly in the lead group; and Manning’s lower standing shows how quickly expectations can shift with uneven results. That said, the odds don’t explain how any individual team will rank its needs or prospects.
For readers tracking the race, the next useful comparison is consistency. Smith has already produced multiple high-yardage games, while Mestemaker’s passing totals have established him as a serious name. Manning’s path back up the board depends on pairing the wins with steadier play. No certainty here, just a clearer set of contenders.
2027 NFL Draft No. 1 pick odds: Jeremiah Smith +150; Drew Mestemaker +250; CJ Carr +350; Darian Mensah +1200; Trinidad Chambliss +1400; Arch Manning +1600; Austin Simmons +2700; LaNorris Sellers +6500.