UCF’s 39-31 double-overtime win over No. 2 BYU turned on a string of decisions and officiating calls that kept reopening the game. The unranked Knights earned the first AP Top 5 victory in program history, while BYU’s undefeated run ended a week after its memorable, disputed win over Notre Dame. The finish had enough reversals to make the final score feel almost like the least surprising part.
A fourth-down gamble leaves UCF empty-handed
With the score tied 24-24 and less than two minutes remaining, UCF had a short field goal available. Head coach Scott Frost chose to go for the touchdown instead. The apparent calculation was that a conversion would put the Knights ahead, while a stop could pin BYU near its own goal line.
Keyone Jenkins was stopped inches short on a quarterback sneak. UCF came away with nothing after a seven-minute drive, giving BYU a chance to take control. Instead, the Cougars went three-and-out, including a run on third-and-6 while UCF still had two timeouts, and punted the ball back.
A review and penalty shift the closing seconds
UCF’s next possession appeared to end in disaster when Jenkins was hit and BYU’s Keanu Tanuvasa seemed to recover the loose ball near field goal range. Replay showed Jenkins had thrown the ball away under pressure, so officials correctly overturned the fumble ruling and called the play incomplete.
There was no intentional-grounding penalty. But Tanuvasa was penalized for unsportsmanlike conduct after shoving UCF lineman Brady Wayburn’s helmet back to the turf. The 15-yard penalty put the Knights in position to attempt a winning field goal, reversing the immediate effect the turnover call would have had.
The blocked kick that should have been tried again
UCF used a spike and a throwaway before Will Stone attempted a 46-yard field goal with 11 seconds left. BYU blocked the kick, but it bounced back to Stone, who advanced it before his helmet came off. Officials initially flagged a face mask, which would have given UCF another opportunity, then picked up the flag and ruled there was no foul.
The play still appeared to give the Knights another chance. Stone had kicked on third down, recovered the ball behind the line of scrimmage and advanced it, so UCF could have attempted a fourth-down kick. Instead, officials applied a 10-second runoff because Stone had to leave the game after losing his helmet. With no timeouts left, regulation ended before another attempt.
That ruling was challenged after the game. Rules analyst Terry McAulay said the runoff should not have applied because the helmet coming off was not the only reason the clock stopped: the play also ended with a legal kick. Under that interpretation, UCF should have had another field goal attempt, with the clock starting on the snap. The missed opportunity added a further officiating dispute to an already crowded finish.
Quarterbacks trade touchdowns in overtime
The overtime periods shifted the story from clock management to execution. BYU struck first in the opening extra period when quarterback Bear Bachmeier found Legend Glasker on third-and-13. Jenkins answered immediately, throwing to Josh Derry for a touchdown to make it 31-31 and force a second overtime.
Those two plays showed why neither team could put the other away. Bachmeier converted a long-yardage situation with a precise throw; Jenkins responded with a touchdown on UCF’s first snap. The game had survived a missed field goal, a disputed runoff and a late defensive stop, only to reset again.
A penalty gives UCF another shot at the end zone
UCF opened the second overtime but stalled at the BYU 8-yard line. Stone made the field goal to put the Knights ahead, then another flag extended the drive. BYU’s Kendal Wall was called for roughing the kicker after colliding with a UCF offensive lineman and Stone as the kick went through.
The call gave UCF a fresh set of downs, and Jenkins took advantage. He found Grayson Brousseau, a Utah native who had entered the game with one reception on the season, for a touchdown. It was Brousseau’s second catch and second touchdown of the year. Tyren Hornes hauled in the two-point conversion on a sliding catch, pushing UCF’s lead to 39-31.
The roughing call was another close judgment in a game already shaped by penalties and clock rulings. Its effect was clear: a made field goal became a goal-to-go opportunity, and UCF turned that extra chance into the touchdown that put BYU under maximum pressure.
UCF’s final stand ends BYU’s perfect run
BYU needed an eight-point score to extend the game into a third overtime and a two-point conversion shootout. Bachmeier scrambled from the 8 to the 4-yard line on first-and-goal, but UCF’s defense then held firm through three straight incomplete passes. On fourth down, Bachmeier’s throw fell short of Walker Lyons.
No flag followed, and the game was over. The closing sequence had given each team a chance to win and left plenty to review, but UCF finished with the decisive play: a goal-line stand against the No. 2 team in the country. With AP Top 10 upsets piling up this season, this one stands out for how many times the result seemed ready to change before the Knights finally secured it.