Week 6 offered three different ways an overlooked player can change the shape of a game. J.J. McCarthy gave the Giants a late chance after entering cold off the bench. Chuba Hubbard supplied the ground game Carolina needed against Philadelphia. And safety Evan Williams helped Green Bay keep Dak Prescott and the Cowboys’ passing attack in check.

Photo by Al Bello/Getty Images | Getty Images

These performances matter for different reasons. McCarthy’s was a glimpse of ability amid a difficult start to his NFL career. Hubbard’s showed how Carolina could exploit a specific weakness in an opposing defense. Williams’ impact came through preparation and movement, helping make a good passing quarterback hesitate. Here are the NFC’s Week 6 Secret Superstars for the 2026 season, alongside the offseason Hidden Gems and the latest AFC and NFC Secret Superstars coverage. Readers can also download the new SB Nation app to follow coverage and join the conversation.

Advanced metrics are from Next Gen Stats, Pro Football Focus, Sports Info Solutions, and Sumer Sports, unless otherwise indicated.

J.J. McCarthy gives the Giants a late opening

McCarthy’s Giants debut looked like a long shot to become a positive story. Minnesota had traded the former 10th overall pick, selected out of Michigan in 2024, to New York on September 28 for a 2027 fifth-round pick. The move came as McCarthy’s first NFL chapter had stalled; New York, meanwhile, needed help after Jaxson Dart suffered a season-ending knee injury.

The Giants turned to veteran Jameis Winston, but his interception against New Orleans with 12:28 remaining prompted head coach John Harbaugh to make a change. McCarthy took over. His first major contribution was an interception of his own, thrown with 10:27 left. At that point, the night appeared headed toward a familiar disappointment.

Instead, McCarthy found a rhythm throwing downfield and scrambling when the pocket broke down. He finished 11 of 23 for 243 yards, one touchdown and one interception, with four explosive passes. Before Sunday, he had recorded 17 explosive passes across his NFL career; he added four in less than a quarter against the Saints.

The context makes the production more striking. New York had led 10-0 in the second quarter before allowing 34 unanswered points. With 12 seconds left, McCarthy had the ball and a chance to tie the game at 34, but his end-zone throw to tight end Isaiah Likely fell incomplete. The play also featured a missed opportunity: Malik Nabers was open in the end zone.

McCarthy wasn’t flawless, but the passing profile fits what the Giants asked him to do. Offensive coordinator Matt Nagy put the ball in his hands for deep throws and gave him room to move when the play broke down. McCarthy also led New York in rushing, with 26 yards on two carries. Next Gen Stats had him tied for the sixth-most fourth-quarter passing yards in a single game this century. His 14.9 air yards per attempt and 17.2 air yards per completion were season highs among quarterbacks with at least 20 dropbacks. He led the NFL in 2025 with 9.3 air yards per attempt and a 42.4% downfield throw rate, so the aggressive approach suits his strengths.

Harbaugh didn’t name a starting quarterback after the game. “It’s not even up for discussion or conversation right now,” he said, adding that the decision would come after the team went back to work. He praised Winston’s competitiveness while acknowledging that the veteran had been up and down. Of McCarthy, Harbaugh said he “did a heck of a job given the circumstances,” made plays, and gave the Giants a chance to win.

One relief appearance won’t settle McCarthy’s future in New York. It did, however, give the Giants a better reason to evaluate him than his first interception suggested.

Chuba Hubbard finds the space Philadelphia left open

Hubbard won this week’s NFC Secret Superstars poll, which also invites readers to vote each week for the AFC and NFC picks.

Carolina beat Philadelphia 25-14 by combining a useful passing day from Bryce Young with a workload that leaned heavily on Hubbard. Young completed 20 of 39 passes for 289 yards, two touchdowns and no interceptions, with a 92.8 passer rating and +0.06 expected points added per pass. That was solid production, but Hubbard’s 120 rushing yards and touchdown on 28 carries gave the Panthers a second way to control the game.

The matchup pointed Carolina toward the edges. Philadelphia’s interior front, with Jalen Carter, Jordan Davis and Moro Ojomo, had allowed only 187 rushing yards at 3.3 yards per carry on 57 runs up the middle or inside to either side through Week 5, according to Sports Info Solutions. Outside and off-tackle runs had been more productive for opponents: 403 yards at 4.4 per carry on 91 attempts.

Carolina adjusted accordingly. Before its Week 5 bye, Hubbard had run inside on 26% of his carries. Against Philadelphia, he went through the A-gaps only five times in 28 attempts. The Panthers kept testing the outside, even as the Eagles changed their fronts, and Hubbard turned that plan into a steady source of yards.

Head coach Dave Canales said the team opened with an 11-yard Hubbard run and hoped to build from there. Philadelphia defensive coordinator Vic Fangio kept presenting new looks, Canales said, but Carolina worked through them and stayed with the run. The approach complemented an offense increasingly built around Young’s development without requiring the quarterback to carry every drive by himself.

Hubbard, a 2021 fourth-round pick from Oklahoma State, now has 426 yards and four touchdowns on 89 carries through five games. His Philadelphia performance showed why Carolina can hand him a heavy workload when the matchup calls for it: he can take repeated carries, make the defense defend the width of the field, and keep the offense on schedule.

Evan Williams helps Green Bay unsettle Dak Prescott

Green Bay’s 23-13 win over Dallas hinged on a defense that made Prescott work for answers. The Cowboys quarterback completed 34 of 54 passes for 258 yards, one touchdown and two interceptions, finishing with a 65.2 passer rating. The Packers showed him looks he didn’t anticipate, and safety Evan Williams was one of the players who helped make those disguises effective.

Williams, a 2024 fourth-round selection from Oregon, recorded seven solo tackles and two quarterback hits. He allowed one completion on one target for seven yards. His interception came from an unexpected spot: he began the play at the line of scrimmage, then raced back to the deep third and jumped Prescott’s skinny-post throw toward CeeDee Lamb. The coverage could have prevented a potential touchdown.

That range helps explain why Prescott often stayed in the pocket searching for an opening. Williams didn’t simply finish plays where he lined up; his movement changed what the offense could expect after the snap. Green Bay’s defense kept shifting the picture, and the resulting hesitation left fewer clean options for a quarterback known for reading defenses before and after the snap.

Williams credited defensive coordinator Jonathan Gannon for putting him in position to make the interception. He said he recognized Lamb in the slot as a likely quick option for Prescott near the red zone, then trusted his instincts and worked into the passing lane. “I put myself between the man and the ball, and the ball showed up,” Williams said.

The box score captures Williams’ tackles and interception; it says less about the uncertainty his movement created. For Green Bay, his Week 6 performance was a reminder that a safety’s value can show up in the throws a quarterback delays or decides against. McCarthy, Hubbard and Williams made their mark in very different ways, but each gave his team something it needed at a pivotal moment.