How scouts turn scattered evidence into a forecast

The most revealing theme in Brendan Gawlowski’s FanGraphs chat is how much prospect evaluation depends on combining evidence: scouting, development, video and data. Asked what evaluators can learn from the Rays and Brewers, Gawlowski pointed to their strong front offices, scouting staffs and player development operations. Their success, he said, reflects how those parts work together. That same approach shapes his individual evaluations. Offseason updates draw on a full year of new information, even when a player’s outlook stays put. Gawlowski reviews video and data, checks for changes such as a new pitch, and revisits what that pitch looks like. Sometimes the forecast moves; often it doesn’t. Either way, the review matters. The chat opened with a question about which of three young catchers—Leo Bernal, Vahn Lackey or Nathan Flewelling—was likeliest to build a solid major league career. Gawlowski chose Lackey, while saying he liked all three. On Flewelling’s defense, especially pitch framing, he described the traits he watches for: mobility, a low stance, a strong wrist and little head movement. Technique can develop, he said, if the physical tools are already there. Flewelling does several things well, staying low and funneling pitches toward the plate from different directions.

Tools can look different in person

Speed grades offer a useful example of why a single number can hide a judgment call. Gawlowski uses home-to-first time as his main reference, then may adjust the grade by half a point based on how playable the speed looks. Watching in the ballpark can reveal a player’s first step on defense or on the bases; some video angles make accurate timing difficult. He recalled a scout who got into trouble after assigning 60 run times to 30 runners from video. The camera angles weren’t synchronized. It’s a small story with a practical lesson: the data is only as dependable as the footage behind it. A reader who had watched Dax Kilby at an Arizona Fall League tripleheader in Goodyear and then at Glendale asked why FanGraphs graded his speed at 55 while MLB and Baseball America had him at 60. The reader had been impressed by Kilby’s speed and by how hard he hit a triple and a ground-rule double. Gawlowski’s answer makes clear that the difference may come down to how evaluators weigh timed runs against what they see on the field.

Scouting grades can change—and sometimes need to

Gawlowski said he’d been too bullish on Kade Anderson in the midseason update after seeing the pitcher use a four-seam fastball with the major league ball. He expects Anderson’s fastball grade to fall. Other judgments are less settled. Charles Davalan has the athleticism and range to play second base, Gawlowski said, but needs more repetitions there. He’s not ready to move Toronto prospect Nimmala off shortstop, though he can increasingly see that possibility. For the Dodgers’ next homegrown starting pitcher, Gawlowski named Zazueta as the current frontrunner. On Susana’s breaking ball, Gawlowski had seen enough separation in velocity between the slowest and fastest versions to treat them as two pitches. Susana may simply have been adding or subtracting speed, he said; either way, Gawlowski likes that he can vary the shape or pace.

Prospect paths rarely run in a straight line

The chat also touched on how player histories complicate old scouting judgments. Asked whether a past report that gave Jurickson Profar a present 70 grade for shortstop defense was mistaken, Gawlowski said injuries played a role, and the grade may have been too high. He added that he was inexperienced at the time. He didn’t see Mickey Moniak in the spring after the outfielder was drafted first overall. But Moniak’s continued appearances in center field in major league games, a decade after his selection, led Gawlowski to question whether athleticism had been the problem. For Jared Grimdlinger, sources with the Los Angeles Angels say the club plans to try a two-way path. That could slow his progress, Gawlowski said, though he finds the experiment exciting. His answer is measured: the plan is known, but the timeline isn’t.

Some questions still have no clean answer

One reader asked whether the Arizona Fall League’s recent performance by Toronto prospect Nimmala signaled a rise. Gawlowski first said Nimmala was holding steady, then added that he might be down a tick. He hasn’t given up on Nimmala at shortstop, but each viewing makes a move away from the position easier to imagine. And spring training planning remains uncertain. Asked whether games would be played in late February the following year, Gawlowski said he had no better forecast than anyone else. His guess was a situation like 2022, perhaps with a few missed games. Travelers who can wait until a few weeks out might find cheaper hotels and lighter crowds at major league games. Those happy to watch on the backfields can make plans now. The fragment ends as Gawlowski is about to answer a question about which Orioles prospects in the Fall League have stood out.

Prospect grades, scouting and player development

Brendan Gawlowski’s read on Honeycutt was modestly positive: the player looked like a 40 FV type, with a better showing at the plate than the label might suggest, though not one that made a major impression. Petey Bienel asked whether Cayden Wallace had done enough to regain the 40 grade he carried in the Kansas City system. Gawlowski said that sounded plausible, but he’d want to examine Wallace’s defense before settling on a grade. Wallace has reached the AA power grade Gawlowski had assigned him for some time; his approach remains a concern. Asked where Ace Reese might settle defensively, Gawlowski’s answer was brief: first base or left field. The larger question about scouting drew a more pointed response. Alex Remington noted that the Mets had decided to add scouts and asked why clubs had cut scouting departments, and whether this World Series matchup might prompt a broader reversal. Gawlowski cited several reasons: some executives believe the data is sufficient without scouts; some dislike the different perspective scouts bring; and, in his view, some scouts have not helped their own case. StuShea asked whether the White Sox should keep Colson Montgomery for another year. Gawlowski said yes: Montgomery’s numbers fell sharply around the time he was hurt, and Gawlowski believes he may have been playing through an issue in the second half. For fans who haven’t visited a club’s backfields, Gawlowski described the setup: teams generally split their minor leaguers into four or five squads, which play near the major league stadium, though there are exceptions, including the Athletics, Giants and Reds/Guardians. Usually two games run at once, featuring either the A and A+ teams or the AA and AAA teams. The crowds tend to be small; scouts, family members and autograph seekers outnumber other fans. His verdict: it’s a good time. Rayball asked for an end-of-season assessment of Josiah Ragsdale. Gawlowski said it was much like the midseason evaluation, and pointed to the [Trade Deadline Prospects Guide: Milwaukee Brewers](https://blogs.fangraphs.com/trade-deadline-prospects-guide-milwaukee-brewers/). On David Hagaman, Gawlowski projected a ceiling as a No. 3 starter and said Hagaman would likely receive a 45 grade this winter, perhaps a 45+. He could reach the desert next year; Gawlowski gave 2027 or 2028 as possible arrival years. He also offered a caveat: ETA is the projection he spends the least time on. Tools are difficult enough to project, and timelines depend on more than talent and performance.

Roster decisions and uncertain projections

A question about the Red Sox’s Story/Arias situation brought a pragmatic answer. Gawlowski called it a good problem to have: Boston could delay Arias’s service clock, while hoping Story is both healthy and effective at shortstop. If Story isn’t, Arias is nearly ready for the position the team wants him to play. Honkus Wagner asked whether Walcott had received enough shortstop work in the AFL to ease defensive concerns, and wondered how Texas would manage Jung and Seager next season. Gawlowski reframed the issue: Walcott will need to keep proving he can play shortstop throughout his career. Pirates Hurdles wondered why Derek Curiel, coming from LSU, hadn’t played in the minors this year, and compared the decision with the approach used for Murf Gray. Gawlowski said it’s fairly typical for first-round picks not to go to A ball at the end of the year. Some do and some don’t; he wouldn’t read much into it. Looking back at players he’d graded too highly, Gawlowski said there were many whose results fell short of their projections, but the choices had reasons behind them. The misses that bother him most are cases where data misled him, such as putting too much weight on metal-bat exit velocities or grading a fastball too highly because of its shape with a minor league ball. Asked more specifically about Dylan Beavers, he said readers could generally trace the reasoning in the original writeup. He wasn’t sure what to expect from the minor league ball after this year’s “rabbit ball.” His guess was that it would move back toward its earlier state, though he added that the league hasn’t been good at producing consistent baseballs. There are only scattered early signals from the 2026 draft class, Gawlowski said. A couple of scouts thought Ace Reece looked more like a hitter than expected, which caught their attention. So far, though, the evidence doesn’t support a verdict that a particular team made a major mistake. InsertWittyNameHere asked whether Gawlowski had seen Aidan Miller in the AFL after Keith Law said Miller looked good. He hadn’t—he kept missing Miller—but thought Eric had seen him a couple of times and suggested asking him. For a dynasty league’s 1.01 pick this winter, Gawlowski said he isn’t a fantasy player, but named PCA, Witt, Elly and Caminero as appealing choices depending on risk tolerance and positional needs. Asked who would start in the Rockies’ outfield on Opening Day 2027, whenever it falls, he answered: Carrigg.

Relievers and workload

The question of whether postseason usage should affect future value grades for late-inning relief prospects doesn’t have an easy answer, Gawlowski said. Relief projections are especially difficult: top relief prospects don’t reliably become dominant closers, and it would have been hard to predict Cade Smith cutting his walk rate in half as soon as he reached the majors. The question came alongside the observation that Smith ran out of gas despite throwing more innings than every Cleveland pitcher except Messick and Williams. Gawlowski said he’s increasingly projecting minor league starters into relief roles while assigning them higher FVs than he might have a few years ago. His point is practical: the uncertainty around relief outcomes makes precise projection difficult, even as clubs ask relievers to handle heavy postseason workloads.

Prospect ceilings and the limits of projection

The clearest reminder from this chat is that prospect rankings describe probabilities, not guarantees. Brendan Gawlowski pushed back on the idea of a “can’t miss” player, citing Ezequiel Tovar: after a 3.5-win 2024 season, Gawlowski would have been stunned to see Tovar’s walk and strikeout numbers improve while his wRC+ fell to 55 two years later. The explanation, he said, was that opposing teams exploited Tovar’s approach. Even a strong recent track record can’t make a hitter immune to adjustment. There was brighter news on top-100 prospects. Asked who might climb next year after a strong second half, Gawlowski expected five to 10 players to rise. He singled out Kilby, said a jump from Luis Hernandez wouldn’t surprise him, and pointed to Michael Arroyo, whose early major league success could move him ahead of Celesten. Kilby’s ceiling is substantial: a .300 hitter with some power and above-average defense at shortstop. Jake Cook’s first professional season drew a cooler assessment: it was “okay,” with his speed playing better on the bases than it had in college. Gawlowski put Cook’s outlook flat or slightly down. That restraint is useful context for anyone reading a midseason surge as a forecast.

Roster value is a moving target

The chat also exposed how much player value depends on the question being asked. One reader preferred a dominant relief pitcher such as Ashby for a seven-game playoff series over a No. 3 starter with a 4.00 FIP, while wondering whether that preference should affect preseason projections. Gawlowski’s answer complicated the comparison: the No. 3 starter might be the fireman reliever. Roles can blur when a team is trying to win a short series. At the amateur level, scouting departments appear to work on both ends of the draft. The top picks get intense attention, including in-person evaluation by multiple decision-makers for players likely to receive seven-figure bonuses. At the same time, scouts keep searching later in the draft for overlooked talent. The discussion leaves open how teams divide those resources, but it doesn’t suggest they’ve abandoned the hunt for depth. One Rockies roster question got a deliberately unexciting answer. After initially mistaking a question about the outfield for one about center field, Gawlowski assumed Colorado would bring back McCarthy and Moniak in the corners. And on the question of whether basketball “works,” his brief complaint was that block, charge, or no call can come down to “just a vibe.”