
Luke Holman’s Arizona Fall League results offer the Cincinnati Reds a promising early look at a pitcher whose first professional seasons have been repeatedly interrupted. In three starts for the Peoria Desert Dogs, the 23-year-old right-hander has given up one run across nine innings, striking out 15 while allowing four hits and one walk.
His latest outing showed how well the mix can play. Holman held the Scottsdale Scorpions scoreless for four innings on Monday, using 52 pitches against a lineup featuring prospects Zyhir Hope, Bryce Rainer and Nathan Flewelling.
A useful read, with more innings ahead
FanGraphs lead prospect analyst Eric Longenhagen sees the ingredients of a back-end starter, while pointing to workload and durability as the open questions. He described Holman’s glove-side fastball command at 92–94 mph and praised a 78–82 mph curveball. Holman also attacks left-handed hitters inside with his fastball and mid-80s cutter-slider, then uses the curve below the strike zone.
“He stretched out to four innings in his most recent start,” Longenhagen said. “Looks like a potential no. 4/5 to me. I want to see how he attacks second/third time through when asked to go six innings, and how his arm strength trends as he gets traction in a full-season routine.”
That workload is the key test. The Reds selected Holman 71st overall in 2024 after his time at Louisiana State University, where his rotation-mates included Kade Anderson and Gage Jump. His pro career began with two effective outings in April 2025, but an elbow injury led to Tommy John surgery and ended his season. A groin issue then limited him to four appearances in the Arizona Complex League this past season.
Holman said the groin problem, rather than his arm, kept him from pitching more. Cincinnati wanted him fully healthy before building toward the Fall League. “My arm actually feels as good as it’s ever felt,” he said.
Fastball gains and a signature curve
Holman says his fastball’s velocity floor has climbed since surgery, and his curveball feels back to its previous form. The slider, which he describes as more of a gyro pitch, remains inconsistent. His higher arm angle doesn’t naturally lend itself to a sweeper shape, and he expects the slider to improve as he gets more innings. He’s also finding a role for his splitter, particularly against left-handed hitters.
“I had a really bad changeup, so I started throwing a splitter a couple years ago,” Holman said. “It will knuckle a little bit here and there, but it’s a true splitter and has been pretty nasty for me.”
The curveball may be his most distinctive offering. Longenhagen previously described it as a high, rainbow-shaped pitch that appears headed well beyond the plate before bending into the strike zone. Holman has thrown it since childhood and says the pitch works especially well alongside the ride on his fastball.
Its shape can buy him a called strike near the top of the zone, then give him room to bury the next one for a chase. Holman said that once hitters see him land the curve for a strike, he can vary its location and use its depth to disguise a pitch aimed below the zone.
Holman isn’t a high-velocity power arm, which makes the quality and command of his secondary pitches central to his outlook. He leaned on the slider in college, but says it has been less consistent since Tommy John surgery. His goal is to command all four pitches for strikes.
For now, the Fall League is giving him the innings he missed and a chance to see how his stuff holds up as his outings lengthen. The early results are strong; the more telling measure will be whether his command, arm strength and secondary pitches remain consistent through a full-season workload.