Ohio State left Bloomington with a 19-15 win that could matter well beyond Saturday. The Buckeyes also left without quarterback Julian Sayin, who will miss “several weeks” with an upper-body injury sustained on a late strip sack. That timing turns a narrow escape into both a résumé boost and a test of Ohio State’s depth.
A win built on defense
Indiana had a chance to complete a statement victory, but the final play never came together. Josh Hoover’s pass to Nick Marsh in the north end zone fell incomplete; Marsh’s foot appeared to touch the boundary, and Ohio State escaped. Ryan Day acknowledged how close the outcome was: “If he catches the ball in the corner of the end zone and his foot's, you know, a yard in, we're all sitting here in a different spot.”
The Buckeyes’ defense gave them a chance to survive. Indiana managed just 73 rushing yards on 29 carries, or 2.5 yards per attempt. That was the Hoosiers’ lowest rushing average since their 2024 College Football Playoff loss to Notre Dame. Ohio State’s defensive front disrupted a ground game that has been central to Curt Cignetti’s team.
Sayin, meanwhile, struggled against Indiana’s pressure and frequent stunts. He completed 15 of 29 passes, about 52 percent, and threw two interceptions: one on a major overthrow and another on a tipped ball. Indiana brought him down four times and kept pressure on him throughout the afternoon. The performance raises questions about Ohio State’s offense, even before the injury changes its quarterback plans.
Sayin’s absence raises the stakes
Day said after the game that Sayin would be out for “several weeks.” The quarterback was later seen wearing a sling around his throwing shoulder. Ohio State now has a bye week to prepare, but the schedule that follows leaves little room to settle in: USC comes next, followed by Oregon and ranked Northwestern, among other demanding opponents.
Luke Fahey entered Saturday in an emergency role. With him potentially taking over while Sayin recovers, the Indiana result offers useful breathing room. A second loss, followed by a backup quarterback stepping into a difficult stretch, would have made the Buckeyes’ path considerably more uncomfortable.
The win also gives Ohio State a valuable result to put before the College Football Playoff selection committee. Injuries can be discussed in committee deliberations, and the Buckeyes now have a high-profile win to weigh alongside their earlier loss at Texas. A defeat to USC in two weeks would still hurt, but Saturday’s result gives the team a stronger case than it would have had after another loss.
Jeremiah Smith makes the difference
Ohio State’s offense found its decisive moment through Jeremiah Smith. On a fourth-down play, Sayin threw toward the right side of the south end zone, where Smith made a touchdown catch between two Indiana defenders. Smith later admitted he had run the wrong route. The throw was imperfect and the coverage was tight, but he adjusted and secured the ball.
“Julian just trusted me,” Smith said. “He just trusted me. I made the play.” The touchdown showed why Smith can change a game even when the offense is under pressure. It also underscored the cost of losing Sayin: Ohio State will have to find ways to keep its top receiver involved while a new quarterback handles a difficult schedule.
A narrow escape, with a demanding stretch ahead
Day described the team as “resilient against a good defense,” and the result supports that assessment. Ohio State won despite Sayin’s uneven performance, two interceptions and a late injury. Still, one close win doesn’t answer every question about the team’s offense or its depth at quarterback.
The bye arrives at a useful moment. Ohio State can regroup, prepare Fahey or another option, and assess Sayin’s recovery before USC arrives. The Buckeyes have a significant win to carry into that stretch. Their next challenge is proving that Saturday’s defensive resolve can hold up while their offense adjusts.