Denver’s 4-2 record masks a widening concern: Bo Nix’s passing has been so cautious and short that the Broncos’ defense is doing much of the work to keep the team competitive. That formula can win games, as the overtime victory over Seattle showed. It also leaves little room for error when the offense needs to answer a stronger opponent.
The numbers through six games are stark. Nix is averaging 4.9 air yards per attempt, the lowest mark over that span in the past 20 years, according to the source data. On Thursday Night Football, his longest completion traveled 7.6 yards through the air, and he went 0-for-3 on attempts beyond 10 yards. In the second half, his average pass distance was behind the line of scrimmage.

A passing game without much depth
Short throws can be part of a sound offense. The concern here is how little Denver has threatened defenses downfield, even when the game has called for it. Nix has often settled for easy completions or thrown the ball away when a window looks difficult. He has 15 throwaways through six games, putting him on pace for 43 over a full season.
That pace alone doesn’t explain the criticism. The more telling question is whether Nix is avoiding risk when the offense needs him to make a play. The source’s author reads his decisions as hesitation rather than smart protection of the ball. That judgment is pointed, but the passing profile gives it a concrete basis: Denver’s attack has offered little vertical threat.
A vocal group of fans still regards Nix as an elite quarterback. The source attributes that support to Broncos fans reluctant to revisit the position, the weight some fans give to quarterback wins, and a particularly devoted group of Nix supporters. But Denver’s record doesn’t erase the gap between its results and its passing production.
The offense is lagging behind the defense
The Broncos allow 20.8 points per game, ninth in the league, while scoring 19.0, good for 26th. Their pass offense ranks 28th. Those figures describe a team staying afloat through defense while struggling to create points consistently.
Former quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick criticized Nix after the Seattle game on Thursday Night Football. He said Nix was “not playing competitively,” pointing to a screen call on third-and-8 that ended in a throwaway and to two chances in overtime to make a decisive play. Fitzpatrick singled out a designed run as an opportunity for Nix to make a defender miss and earn a first down.
Fitzpatrick also questioned the effect on Denver’s coaching staff and offensive line. When a quarterback doesn’t challenge defenses, the burden shifts to the rest of the offense to find ways to sustain drives. Receivers get fewer chances to make plays, and the team’s scoring ceiling shrinks.
“Bo Nix is not playing competitively. It’s almost disrespectful to the quarterback position, how he’s playing football. Frst of all: The guy doesn’t want to throw the ball, that’s fine. He’s throwing to the flats, he’s throwing behind, but he has no trust from his coach. He calls a screen play on 3rd & 8, just run up and let the clock keep going. What’s he do? He throws it away. Seattle gets the ball, they have a timeout. And then in overtime, he’s got two chances to be competitive. The last one being a designed run for him to run, make somebody miss, and get a first down for your football team! Now, they’re in the locker room right now, they’re excited, they won. He’s not playing competitive football right now.”
Postseason tests the same question
Denver’s defense has helped the team reach 4-2, but the offense’s ranking suggests the current balance may be difficult to sustain against stronger teams. The source points to past quarterbacks such as Trent Dilfer, Brad Johnson and Nick Foles, who elevated their play when the stakes rose. For Nix, the practical test is whether he can add a downfield threat and take the necessary chances before Denver’s defense runs out of room to cover for the offense.