Dallas built its offseason around fixing a defense that had already finished last in the NFL. Five games into 2026, that plan has produced a unit allowing even more yards, struggling to stop the run and yet to intercept a pass. The result is a 2-3 Cowboys team whose offense is scoring well enough to contend, but whose defense keeps turning that potential into a weekly problem.
Dallas’ defensive overhaul hasn’t changed the results
The Cowboys conceded 30 points per game in 2025. New defensive coordinator Christian Parker arrived with a deep roster of additions intended to change the picture: Dallas traded for edge rusher Rashan Gary and linebacker Dee Winters, signed safety Jalen Thompson and edge rusher Von Miller, and drafted safety Caleb Downs and edge rusher Malachi Lawrence.
So far, the numbers point in the wrong direction. Dallas is allowing 18 more yards per game than it did last season and leads the league in rushing yards allowed, at 168 per game. The defense has not intercepted a pass through five games. Even the Jets, who went without an interception throughout 2025, have already recorded one this season. Dallas’ third-down defense was the league’s worst last year; it is now allowing conversions at an even higher rate.
Thursday’s home game against the winless Tampa Bay Buccaneers offered a chance to show that the offseason changes were taking hold. Instead, Dallas let an undrafted rookie quarterback guide Tampa Bay on a 15-play possession that consumed 10 minutes and 58 seconds. The Buccaneers had managed six points across their first four opening drives, then scored seven on the extended march. It gave the visitors control of the game’s rhythm.
“We were gassed,” Buccaneers offensive tackle Tristan Wirfs said of the drive. “But seeing them, they were tired, too. They weren’t expecting us to come out like that. That felt really good.”
Tampa Bay, an eight-point underdog playing on a short week, went on to win 24-16. Dallas fell to 2-3, and owner Jerry Jones described the defense’s shortcomings as “mind-boggling.” He said the unit was “right where we started.” That assessment captures the gap between the Cowboys’ offseason expectations and what they have put on the field.
The offense can’t cover for the defense forever
Dak Prescott and the Dallas offense are averaging 27.6 points per game, a figure exceeded by only four NFL teams: the Bills, Ravens, Lions and 49ers. Those four teams have combined for a 16-4 record. Dallas, despite a comparable scoring output, is 2-3 and looking up at the Giants in a flawed, still-winnable NFC East.
The difference is what happens when the opposing offense has the ball. Dallas has five sacks in five games, and no Cowboys defender has more than one. The contrast will be hard to miss at Lambeau Field, where the Packers have recorded 14 sacks even without Micah Parsons, the All-Pro edge rusher they acquired from Dallas before last season. Parsons is recovering from a torn ACL and won’t play Sunday, but Green Bay has found ways to pressure quarterbacks without him.
Dallas has already made a notable move to address its own secondary, trading a 2028 second-round pick for cornerback Joey Porter from the Steelers. Porter could help once he has settled into the defense, but the trade also shows how quickly the Cowboys have felt compelled to act. Jones has faced questions about coaching changes. Rather than fire Parker, the team brought in veteran coach Mike Pettine as a consultant. Pettine gave Parker his first NFL job as Green Bay’s defensive coordinator, making him a familiar resource for the coach now under pressure to produce better results.
The next two games could shape the conversation. A win at Green Bay would matter even with Parsons sidelined, particularly after the Packers scored 31 points against Chicago and have reason to show they can win without him. Dallas then visits Philadelphia on Monday night in Week 7. The Eagles are also 2-3 and have scored 24 points or fewer in each of their five games.
Two losses would deepen the Cowboys’ troubles, especially if their defense continues to give up points and long possessions. Parker’s schedule beyond that includes the 49ers, Seahawks and Jaguars. A losing season and a missed playoff berth would also put head coach Brian Schottenheimer’s position under scrutiny. For now, the clearest test is whether Dallas can make its defensive spending and coaching changes show up in the results.
A tie leaves its own questions
The Cowboys’ division provided another talking point Sunday, when the Commanders and Giants played to an overtime tie. It was only the NFL’s second tie in four seasons, but the rarity does little to make the outcome satisfying. A game can finish without a winner even after both teams have had extra time to find one.
There’s a case for changing the format. A 15-minute overtime period, followed by another if the score remains level, would keep the possibility of a decisive result alive. The drawback is practical: longer games strain players and disrupt television schedules. Requiring teams to attempt two-point conversions after touchdowns in a second overtime could help shorten the process, though it wouldn’t guarantee a quick finish.
The tie was unusual, but its effect on the standings and the fan experience is plain. A game that ends without a winner leaves both teams with an awkward result to carry into the next week. Whether the NFL changes its overtime rules or not, Sunday’s game has renewed a simple question: how much value is there in preserving a tie when neither team has won?
Miami faces a far steeper climb
The Dolphins have long had a reason to watch the league’s final unbeaten team fall: Miami’s 1972 team remains the NFL’s only squad to finish a season undefeated. This year’s team is facing a very different milestone. Miami is 0-5, owns the league’s worst point differential at minus-62, and has started with little sign that a turnaround is close.
Fewer than three wins in a season would be rare for the franchise. The Dolphins have done it only once, finishing 1-15 in 2007. Three wins look difficult to reach from here, particularly with the team’s roster and schedule working against it. Before the season, divisional games against the Jets appeared to offer Miami two of its better chances. New York has already won twice, making next Sunday’s matchup less inviting than it once looked.
Quarterback Malik Willis has limited support. Miami is without a legitimate group of receiving threats, and running back De’Von Achane is out for the season with a torn ACL. Willis entered the year with a chance to show the Dolphins they could avoid using a high first-round pick on a quarterback. Five games in, the case has not come together: he has thrown two touchdown passes.
Among the 34 seasons in which a Dolphins quarterback has thrown at least as many touchdown passes through the first five weeks, none produced fewer than Willis’ two. His quarterback rating is also the worst of those seasons since the NFL-AFL merger. Those numbers don’t settle Miami’s longer-term decisions, but they underline how little the offense has offered so far.
Dallas still has an offense capable of keeping games competitive, while Miami is searching for its first win and a quarterbacking foothold. Both teams enter the next stretch with urgent questions. The Cowboys need their defensive overhaul to become visible on the field; the Dolphins need to find a way to make their limited options count. Their early records suggest that those problems will define the weeks ahead.