(Photo by John Fisher/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Los Angeles has a hard decision coming into Game 3 of the NLCS: whether to keep Shohei Ohtani in the lineup while his production and visible swing strength have fallen off. The Dodgers return home trailing the Milwaukee Brewers 2-0, and manager Dave Roberts says he plans to talk with Ohtani about what serves the player and the team.

Ohtani is 3-for-20 this postseason, with three singles and three walks. He went hitless in four at-bats with two strikeouts in Game 2 after collecting one single in Game 1. His postseason line stands at .150/.261/.411. Those numbers make a lineup change plausible, even for a player whose value and profile usually make a benching unthinkable.

A prolonged slide behind the playoff numbers

The downturn predates the NLCS. Ohtani hit .293/.403/.549 with 22 home runs before the All-Star break. In the second half, he fell to .245/.325/.447 with eight home runs. The month-by-month figures show the decline: after a .273/.330/.557 July with six homers, he hit .241/.322/.472 in August, also with six home runs.

His final eight regular-season games in September and October brought a .200/.333/.233 line and no home runs. Ohtani’s last homer came on August 18 against Colorado. During that three-game series at Coors Field, he went 5-for-14 with three homers and five runs batted in. Since then, he has gone 14-for-90, with no home runs and one RBI, batting .156 with an OPS below .490.

The postseason slump is unfolding against a season shaped by injuries. A left knee problem cost Ohtani some starts on the mound during the summer and kept him out of the All-Star Game while he sought treatment. He later dealt with a right bicep issue, landed on the injured list in September and was shut down as a pitcher on September 7.

What the swing is showing

Ohtani’s recent contact offers another clue to the problem. FanGraphs data puts his bat speed on line drives at 74.8 mph, below last year’s 76.0 and his 2023 high of 77.7. His only hit in the NLCS came off the bat at 74 mph, a sharp drop from his 93.3 mph average exit velocity this season.

That single also reflected a change in approach. The Athletic reported that Ohtani has tried to shorten his swing and hit the ball toward the opposite field, adjustments that may help him make contact while he struggles to catch up with fastballs and pull them.

In the first inning Monday, Milwaukee’s Logan Henderson struck him out on a 95 mph four-seam fastball high in the zone. Later, Ohtani struggled to hold onto his bat while trying to poke a pitch off the plate the other way. He had also shown bunt at the start of that at-bat, an unusual look from a power hitter who has often attacked pitches with a full swing.

Roberts faces a lineup and health question

Roberts acknowledged after the loss that Ohtani hasn’t looked right. “Yeah, I mean, obviously it hasn’t been good. He doesn’t feel great,” he said, according to The Athletic. Roberts said he would speak with Ohtani the next day to decide what is best for both him and the club, adding that Ohtani “certainly has earned that conversation and deserves it.”

Dodgers writer Eric Stephen read Roberts’ comments as a sign that Ohtani might not start Wednesday’s Game 3 at Dodger Stadium. That interpretation remains an expectation, not a confirmed lineup decision. The club was scheduled to speak with media on the off day before the game, when more information about Ohtani’s status could emerge.

Ohtani offered a more upbeat assessment of his swing ahead of the NLDS, speaking through team interpreter Will Ireton. “It feels really good overall,” he said. “I do feel like my swing is in a better place, feels smooth, and just a little tweaks here and there, and I’ll be ready for tomorrow.”

He also said he hadn’t identified the root cause of his physical problems and expected to address that during the offseason. For now, he said, he would have to manage them. On the decision to go on the injured list, Ohtani described a discussion centered on what would help the team: whether he could play through the issue, and whether recovery would better position him for the postseason.

That history makes Roberts’ planned conversation consequential. Ohtani’s own account suggests the Dodgers weighed immediate availability against his ability to recover, while the current slump raises questions about how much he can contribute at the plate. The choice will turn on what Ohtani reports about his condition as well as what the team sees in his at-bats.

A potential replacement is already on the roster

If Ohtani sits, Josue De Paula is a leading candidate to take his place, according to The Athletic. The Dodgers called up De Paula from Double-A Tulsa in mid-September. In limited regular-season action, he went 10-for-31 with a home run and a .323/.500/.581 line, earning a spot on the postseason roster. He has drawn two walks in three postseason plate appearances, including one in Game 1.

De Paula’s small sample doesn’t answer what the Dodgers lose by taking Ohtani out of the lineup. It does give Roberts an available option if the club decides that Ohtani’s health or current form makes a start unwise. With Los Angeles two losses from elimination, Game 3 will test whether the team believes its biggest star can help turn the series around—or needs time on the bench to get there.