A weekly chat, with the postseason in the foreground

Jay Jaffe opened his October 13, 2026, Fangraphs chat still getting used to the site’s new internal platform. Readers need to be logged in to submit questions; a paid membership isn’t required. Jaffe said he had a piece on Victor Mesa Jr. in the pipeline for that day, and pointed to his previous day’s American League Championship Series preview:
his preview of the Rays facing the Guardians. With the queue quiet, he invited readers to send questions. The postseason thread ran from Hall of Fame cases to the Dodgers’ precarious position. One reader asked how José Ramírez’s memorable October might affect his Cooperstown chances. Jaffe’s view: the postseason can help, but Ramírez has already done most of the work. His 44.7 JAWS peak score is above the third baseman peak standard of 43.4, though he hasn’t reached the position’s overall JAWS standard. He was at 297 home runs and 1,779 hits; reaching 300 homers and 2,000 hits should bring added attention, and another World Series appearance would bolster his case. Jaffe also said he had a piece planned for later that week about Ramírez’s recovery from a slump. The changing playoff odds prompted a practical answer: Jaffe hadn’t checked the Dodgers’ numbers, but new starting pitcher announcements or lineup adjustments could explain a shift from below 25% to above it. The projections change as new information comes in. And with Los Angeles down 2–0, Jaffe agreed that a Brewers–Guardians or Brewers–Rays World Series could strengthen the MLB Players Association’s position heading into collective bargaining, while putting owners in a tougher public position. Asked which of the remaining teams he wanted to see win, Jaffe said his Dodgers upbringing still shaped his instincts. Among the other National League clubs, he watches the Brewers and Padres most, with the Mets also familiar for geographic reasons; if pressed, he’d pick Milwaukee. The Brewers, Rays, and Guardians also appeal to him because they’re among baseball’s more analytically inclined teams. He cited Gabe Lacques’s USA Today piece on the teams’ connections. On Shohei Ohtani, Jaffe was less certain. The debate over whether to bench him reminded him of the 2024 World Series, when the Dodgers kept his shoulder condition closely guarded and his value in the lineup may have included acting as a decoy. Ohtani’s at-bats hadn’t been good, and he hadn’t pulled a ball in the air since August. With the Dodgers trailing 2–0, Jaffe said he might consider using DePaula, but acknowledged that Ohtani’s actual condition wasn’t clear. The chat also ranged well beyond the current series. A reader asked about *King of the Mound*, a book about Satchel Paige and his time with the integrated Bismarcks. Jaffe hadn’t read it and didn’t recall much about the Bismarcks, but said Larry Tye’s 2009 biography, *Satchel: The Life and Times of an American Legend*, covers them and is a book he enjoyed. On MLB’s proposed changes to season and playoff length, Jaffe was unimpressed but thought the proposal was less objectionable than the league’s other trial balloons during what he called its propaganda cycle. If the schedule is shortened, he said, 154 games is the obvious starting point. His skepticism centered on what owners might do next: propose cutting salaries by 5% to match the shorter season, which he predicted would kill the idea. A reader wondered whether players on eliminated teams root for smaller-budget clubs because a Brewers title could affect bargaining. Jaffe thought most players are more focused on recovering from the season; personal ties to players, coaches, or executives are more likely to shape their rooting interests. He also argued that even moving the mound back one foot could change how pitchers work. His concern is that pitchers would try to preserve their current velocity by exerting more effort, potentially adding stress to their arms. JAWS—the system Jaffe developed to assess Hall of Fame cases—came up in a different context, too. He has considered applying it to managers and coaches, but hasn’t found a useful version to present. A medical journal had cited JAWS for a “peak plus average” study unrelated to sports. If there’s a lockout, he joked, he’ll return to the project. The most entertaining idea for him is “Astronaut JAWS,” fitting his interest in spaceflight, Apollo documentaries, and science fiction films where people put on helmets. On Hall of Fame voting, Jaffe predicted that Dustin Pedroia could gain momentum by following Chase Utley’s lead, with Andruw Jones also part of the comparison. He thought Andy Pettitte might pick up support as voters recognize that the Era Committee is unlikely to help him, given the Hall’s engineered panels. Asked about active pitchers who could follow Chris Sale’s late-career revival, Jaffe named Gerrit Cole, Zack Wheeler, and Jacob deGrom as needing to make further progress. He had written about them in August: his Cooperstown notebook on Sale and other pitchers. Max Fried might be another possibility: he has pitched well but lacks volume, with just one season above 5.0 WAR. The fragment ends with a reader asking what role the Dodgers might choose for Ohtani if he’s healthy enough to pitch—particularly whether they could use him as a reliever even if they don’t need him in the starting rotation.

Rules, rosters and a Phillies reset

A rule designed to keep a two-way star in the spotlight can create a problem if he enters as a reliever: once he leaves the mound, he must take a fielding position to stay in the game. That exception limits how useful the rule is in that role. Jay Jaffe is cautiously positive about Joe Espada as a possible Mariners manager. He hasn’t seen a reason to call Espada a poor fit, and says Seattle hiring him would look like a solid move unless a stronger candidate emerged. For the Phillies, Jaffe sees a more urgent need for change. He compares bringing back interim manager Don Mattingly to putting Trea Turner back at shortstop and counting on Aaron Nola to lead the rotation: a waste of time with the clock running. Possible alternatives include coaches Kai Correa, Ruben Niebla and George Lombard Sr., or experienced managers David Ross, Rocco Baldelli and Espada. In the end, much may depend on whom Dave Dombrowski connects with. The Phillies resemble their 2010–11 predecessors in needing an overhaul, Jaffe says, though the comparison has limits. He views Turner as a bigger concern than Bryce Harper, and points out that the current club has Cristopher Sánchez and Jesús Luzardo under long-term control. The earlier team had Cliff Lee beyond the 2014 option for Roy Halladay, which the club declined. A rebuild isn’t the only imaginable route, but the roster needs more than a small adjustment.

Small experiments, big questions

One fan proposed narrowing the pitching rubber by a few inches on each side, limiting pitchers’ ability to exploit angles and disguise their deliveries. Jaffe would consider trying it in the Arizona Fall League or Atlantic League to see what happens. The idea fits a broader debate about pitcher advantage, though a change to the mound could prompt pitchers to push even harder for velocity. Jaffe’s point is blunt: players will keep chasing upper-tier fastballs before they decide they need a new pitch. He’s less persuaded by an AFL experiment restricting outfielder positioning, despite a fan’s proposed nickname, the “Strawberry Patch” rule, after Darryl Strawberry. Jaffe objects to the amount of technology involved. His preferred ways to increase offense are more conventional: move the fences back and raise them, or revisit the strike-zone boundaries and possibly check-swing calls.

October’s possible storylines

A World Series between Milwaukee and Tampa Bay would guarantee a first title for one club, a rare outcome by one fan’s count: only one Series in the past century featured two teams that had never won it. Jaffe likes the prospect, but doesn’t want that storyline to eclipse the others. Cleveland’s long wait for a championship matters, given the organization’s high quality over more than 30 years. A Dodgers comeback would set up a rematch of either the 1920 or 2020 Series and put the club in pursuit of only the fifth three-peat in baseball history—and the first by an NL team. And, as Jaffe jokes, there’s always the possibility of a Padres–Mariners World Series someday. The October lineup debate is less compelling to him. Calls to shake up the Dodgers’ order after two games overlook Kyle Tucker’s .300/.391/.500 postseason line and Max Muncy’s .684 slugging percentage. Jaffe says a specific matchup against the Game 3 starter, Robert Gasser, could change the calculus, but doesn’t see Gasser as a reason to overhaul the lineup. Shohei Ohtani’s workload is another case where expectations may need recalibrating. Jaffe doubts we’ll see him pitch 200 innings again, and would be surprised by 162. If healthy, he sees 100–120 innings as a more plausible target while Ohtani also hits. That’s still an extraordinary two-way workload, but it’s a different one from a traditional starter’s season.

What success does—and doesn’t—prove

A Tampa Bay or Cleveland matchup with Milwaukee might be used to argue against a salary cap, or to suggest teams can win without spending heavily in free agency. Jaffe thinks that misses the central point: these clubs are in the Championship Series because they’re well run and search for advantages. Their approach can work, but simply refusing to spend doesn’t reproduce it. That distinction also matters in assessing Milwaukee manager Pat Murphy. A fan points to his possible third straight NL Manager of the Year award, a regular-season winning percentage said to rank among the top 25 in history, and the prospect of leading the Brewers to their first World Series. Jaffe still sees a Hall of Fame case as a long shot. Murphy is already 67, and Milwaukee’s current success may be harder to sustain as its core gets more expensive and pitchers face injuries. A few losing seasons could change how the career looks in retrospect; the late start leaves little margin for that. Jaffe is similarly skeptical that a new book will do much to boost George Steinbrenner’s Hall of Fame prospects. Mike Vaccaro’s book may be a good read, but Jaffe expects little influence on committee decisions. Steinbrenner received fewer than five votes in both 2017 and 2019, which could count against another candidacy under the newer rule. Jaffe also doubts the Hall wants to induct an owner who was suspended twice. On the broader question of Hall voting, he’d consult on committees if he could keep his FanGraphs job and voting privileges, but doesn’t expect to join the Hall’s payroll. The same independence, Jaffe argues, should apply to Giants beat writers who vote on awards involving Buster Posey, now an executive. A reader worries about the conflict of interest and the pressure on local reporters. Jaffe points to the criticism Posey drew during his mistakes that year and trusts reporters to separate the player from the executive. One related read Jaffe shared: Victor Mesa Jr. Has Hardly Plateaued.

What the numbers can—and can’t—tell us

The same lesson runs through several of these questions: a headline stat can point you toward an answer, but it rarely explains the whole thing. The Dodgers’ spending works because of how they deploy it; Milwaukee’s restraint works alongside heavy investment in areas other clubs neglect. Both approaches look easy to copy from a distance. The many teams that have failed to reproduce either one suggest otherwise. That’s also true of the new pitch challenge system. Simple success rates miss how often a player could have challenged, how bad the original call was, how much the moment mattered, and how many challenges remained. Statcast’s Savant data already includes leverage and has added an adjustment for losing a challenge, though the choices behind those numbers remain debatable. It’s a start. Players and managers are still learning the system, and teams may be developing more sophisticated ways to evaluate it. There’s less to go on in the talk of a juiced ball in the minors. Jay Jaffe wanted data before drawing conclusions: Pacific Coast League scoring fell, while International League scoring rose but remained below its 2023–24 levels. A reader added an important caveat: Double-A and lower use a different ball, so those leagues’ scoring can’t be inferred from PCL and IL results. Jaffe said the point rang a bell. Until the lower-level numbers are clear, the claim deserves scrutiny, not certainty.

Milwaukee’s choices carry into October

The Brewers’ bullpen has been a strength, but pushing it hard through a postseason run carries a cost. Jaffe expects bullpen management to change as the series progress: the Division Series has extra off days, while the League Championship Series is a different test. Usage may balance out, and familiarity with opposing hitters will start to matter more. That same pragmatism may shape the market for Bauers. Jaffe sees a two- or three-year contract as a likely outcome. Milwaukee could make him a qualifying offer while also signaling that a longer-term arrangement is available. The reader’s suggested two years and $30 million was a question, not a settled valuation.

Some old Hall of Fame markers have already shifted

The 500-home-run and 300-win milestones no longer carry the automatic force they once did; voters increasingly account for how rare those totals have become. But Jacob deGrom’s case may require a bigger change in how the Hall weighs careers. Jaffe wasn’t convinced by the case in the piece he’d linked earlier, even while the reader argued that anyone who watched deGrom pitch has seen an all-time great. The disagreement points to the tension: peak performance can be extraordinary, while the traditional counting stats still leave a short career difficult to assess. There are no easy formulas here. Whether teams are building rosters, managing challenges, or weighing a player’s Hall of Fame case, the useful numbers need context—and the context is often still catching up. Enjoy the baseball. Source