Prospects, tools and the limits of a short look
Brendan Gawlowski opened the FanGraphs chat with “Hello everybody.” What followed was a wide-ranging exchange about prospect rankings, defensive development and how much a few games can change an evaluation. The clearest thread: a prospect’s ceiling matters, but so does the likelihood that he’ll reach the majors as a regular.
That distinction came up in a question about Jhonny Level, whom a reader felt was being overlooked among the Giants’ young middle infielders. Gawlowski had seen him several times. Level doesn’t match the younger players’ defensive ability or upside, he said, and needs to become more selective at the plate. Still, he’s a good hitter with sneaky power and, in Gawlowski’s view, an easy top-100 prospect. Prospect fatigue may already be creeping in.
Dax Kilby offered a related case. Gawlowski sees less “freaky, elite upside” than with Walcott, but views Kilby as a likely regular: a solid shortstop with a strong feel for hitting. He also named Kilby and Flewelling as personal risers since the midseason reports, while saying Bernal had probably played his way onto the top 100.
Asked to compare Spencer Jones and Lazaro Montes as versions of the Joey Gallo archetype, Gawlowski said they reach a similar destination by different routes. He’d lean toward Jones, though the two are close in his personal preference.
Development takes time
Tai Peete’s progress after moving into the Cardinals’ organization drew a question about whether he could become a top-100 candidate. Gawlowski credited the decision to repeat High-A. Peete still swings and misses too often for a realistic top-100 case, but the rate didn’t spike after his promotion to Double-A. Gawlowski also cautioned that plenty of prospects with everyday-player upside sit outside a list of 100 or even 110 names.
On defense, the evaluation depends on where a player is in his development. For a teenager on a complex team, speed and athleticism matter, as do good hands and an infielder’s feel for the hop; reliability matters less at that stage. By Triple-A or the majors, the standard rises: the player needs to make the plays an average defender at that position would handle.
That doesn’t mean instincts are fixed. Players can improve at tracking fly balls and reading ground-ball hops, Gawlowski said, but strong instincts provide a better starting point, and some players have a lower ceiling than others. He described Bonemer’s early outfield work as raw, but not surprising: players often struggle in their first exposure, especially in center field. A few dozen games may be needed before there’s a meaningful read on their instincts.
Small samples came up again with Davalan’s early struggles in the Arizona Fall League. Gawlowski’s answer was brief: “It’s a handful of games.” He also dismissed concern about Alexander Frias’s numbers dropping after a trade with a one-word reply: “No.”
What moves a prospect’s outlook?
A postseason run can change an evaluation, but the bar is high. Asked whether Josue De Paula could meaningfully improve his standing if he plays a larger role for the Dodgers in a short series, Gawlowski pointed to Arozarena as the clearest example of a player who earned a significantly higher grade through postseason performance alone.
And a slump in a tough league is hard to interpret without more evidence. A reader wondered whether Davalan’s Arizona Fall League results reflected a focus on defense, stronger competition or random variation; Gawlowski didn’t try to assign a cause from a handful of games.
Systems, scouting and what comes next
The Giants’ farm system has climbed sharply in the rankings over the past year, but Gawlowski wouldn’t call its rise unmatched. St. Louis has a case, too, and Atlanta has gained ground from a lower position. Asked to rank five Giants prospects, he gave this order: Flora, Marquez, Keyner, Bresnahan, Cayama.
The Angels’ farm system isn’t nonexistent, Gawlowski said, though its prospects are mostly a ways off. Rada could help in 2027, but he expects a rough major league season regardless of what the team does. A reader framed the alternative as owner Stan Kroenke spending to fill the club’s many roster holes; Gawlowski’s answer focused on the distance between the farm’s talent and the major league roster.
On scouting, he saw advantages and drawbacks in both the pre-draft era, when scouts might arrive without knowing whom they were watching, and today’s world of video, radar and advance information. The older days might have been a little more fun, he said, though travel logistics were brutal. Teams also do their homework on draft picks’ off-field backgrounds; he wasn’t sure whether they hire private investigators.
A few lighter exchanges rounded out the chat. Gawlowski rejected the idea that prospects with boring names are more likely to be underrated, despite John Sickels’s theory and Brad Miller as a remembered example. Asked whether chase rate, in-zone contact or contact against pitches at 95 mph and above was the bigger concern for a hitter, he replied: “Depends; who do you have in mind?” And on Angeibel Gomez, he pointed readers to [his fall instructional league notes on the Royals, Giants and Padres](https://blogs.fangraphs.com/fall-instructional-league-notes-royals-giants-padres/).
The habits behind Milwaukee’s offense
Home runs matter more in October because postseason games tend to have fewer runners and fewer runs. A long ball can therefore account for a bigger share of the scoring. But a short series is also a noisy sample, and teams can win in several ways. Milwaukee, Cleveland and Tampa Bay ranked 29th, 27th and 22nd in home runs, and sat between 25th and 27th in ISO. Their postseason success doesn’t overturn the case for power; it shows that power isn’t the only route.
Milwaukee’s more durable advantage appears to be its hitters’ approach and contact, paired with a willingness to run hard. The club has maintained the best on-base percentage and nearly the best walk rate over the past couple of seasons despite limited power. As Brendan Gawlowski echoed from Sam Miller’s newsletter, a team that hustles in a league that often doesn’t can find an edge. Milwaukee doesn’t turn every ground ball into value, but it gets more out of infield grounders than anyone else.
Prospects require patience
The jump from Double-A to consideration for a Dodgers playoff start says plenty about Josue De Paula’s ability. Gawlowski’s assessment was brief: “He’s very good.”
Projecting players much earlier is a different job. Gawlowski has no personal experience scouting young players overseas, and said Latin American clubs vary in how organized their scouting is. But even a well-run operation can only see so far with a 14-year-old; many pitchers don’t stand out until their late teens. At A-ball, no one can reliably predict how much WAR a 20-year-old will produce over a career. Size, athleticism, tools and room for physical growth can help identify who has a chance to make an impact, though they don’t settle the question.
That uncertainty is also why prospect timelines deserve restraint. Gawlowski would be surprised to see S. Walcott on the major league roster next spring: he’s blocked, and a scout made the case that he’d benefit from a full season in Triple-A. J. Farmelo also doesn’t look close to a fast track. He could spend most or all of 2027 in Double-A; even a season in the 85th to 90th percentile might only get him to Triple-A late in the summer.
Readiness matters as much as upside
For Seattle, Gawlowski would be comfortable with Young at second base next year, but he’d want a capable backup plan for Emerson at shortstop. He still expects Emerson to become a good player, yet wouldn’t count on him as an everyday, plug-and-play shortstop from opening day on a team trying to contend.
Other evaluations carry similar caveats. Gawlowski expects George Lombard Jr. to stay at shortstop and thinks he can be above average there, even while acknowledging he’s lower on Lombard’s defense than other evaluators. Justin Gonzales has eye-catching power and plenty in his favor, but an unusual swing and stiffer movement make an elite outcome harder to call. Gawlowski’s view: wait and see.
In Toronto, Ryan Sprock is likely to appear on Gawlowski’s nearly finished prospect list, probably with a 40 grade, unless his sources are much more enthusiastic than expected. For Sam Horn, Gawlowski pointed to his [Arizona Fall League pitcher scouting notebook](https://blogs.fangraphs.com/arizona-fall-league-pitcher-scouting-notebook/).
And if a pitching prospect wants to experiment with a knuckleball, Gawlowski is all for it. He thinks more players should give the pitch a try.
Public hype can outrun scouting
Jasson Dominguez’s reputation may have been shaped by a gap between public expectations and how baseball evaluators viewed him, both in public reports and inside teams. Gawlowski said Eric has suggested the baseball card market could help explain the intensity of the hype around Yankees prospects, a theory he finds plausible. The scouting expectation, he said, was a regular rather than a star—and players with that projection fall short often.
Dominguez could still have another useful run. Gawlowski said a return as a 110–115 wRC+ hitter, with shaky defense in some role and perhaps more playing time against right-handers than left-handers, wouldn’t surprise him.
In the comparison between Emma Rodriguez and Mike Sirota, both the same age and with broadly similar offensive profiles, Rodriguez’s injury history contributes to the gap in their grades. The larger concern, according to Gawlowski, is that Rodriguez appears vulnerable across a much wider part of the strike zone than Sirota.
What scouts see that fans miss
The gap between a scout’s enthusiasm and a player’s public reputation can be wide. Brendan Gawlowski points to the A’s being especially high on Esteury Ruiz, and says scouts often gravitate toward players with standout tools even when the underlying data raises concerns. Spencer Jones is his own example: after watching him twice, Gawlowski liked what he saw but hadn’t registered how much online discussion had turned his strikeouts into a punchline.
That disconnect cuts both ways. Hao-Yu Lee’s rookie season was solid without settling whether he has another level; Gawlowski hopes he does, though Lee’s defensive limits make a useful reserve role the sensible projection for now.
Small samples, real questions
Muni’s trouble with fastballs in the zone showed against Cleveland, prompting a question about whether playoff pitchers can target that weakness more consistently than regular-season opponents. Gawlowski’s answer was measured: postseason competition is tougher, but a short series can distort the picture. He cited two five-game stretches from the regular season. From August 1–6, Muni hit .136/.208/.182, with 12 strikeouts and one double in 24 plate appearances. From May 6–12, he hit .111/.238/.278 with 12 strikeouts in 21 plate appearances against the Angels, Mariners and Royals.
Those numbers don’t settle whether pitchers have found a lasting blueprint. They do show why a poor October stretch alone can’t prove that they have.
The same caution applies to prospect statistics in a lively minor-league hitting environment. Asked whether Kellon Lindsay’s and Joendry Vargas’s numbers were inflated, Gawlowski said the effect applied to everyone this year. On Carson Williams, he was blunt: he doesn’t think Williams will hit.
Roster fits and ranking limits
Gawlowski had no new Braves information beyond what he’d published in the AZ notes, though he expects Atlanta to appear fairly early in the list cycle. Ethan Salas’s performance with the Padres is unlikely to shift his ranking much: he’s already No. 10 on FanGraphs’ board, leaving little room to rise.
For Toronto’s Sean Keys, Gawlowski sees practical ways to make room. The Jays could try him in left field, use him as a pinch hitter or give him time at designated hitter; if the bat plays, they’ll find opportunities. He dismissed the idea of turning Keys into Tanner Bibee, but remained open to testing his defense in the outfield.
And on Adael Amador, there was no victory lap. Gawlowski was simply glad the Colorado prospect is relevant again, and cautiously believes a regular player may still be in there.