Cleveland’s comeback has turned a Division Series that looked settled into a test of baseball’s narrowest margin: one game. After losing the first two games at home to the Chicago White Sox, the Guardians scored nine runs in each of two road wins to tie the series. Game 5 at Progressive Field will decide who faces the Tampa Bay Rays in the American League Championship Series—and whether Cleveland joins a short list of teams that recovered from an 0-2 deficit in a best-of-five Division Series.
Since the Division Series became a permanent part of the postseason in 1995, seven teams have won three straight after dropping the first two games. The 1981 Dodgers also rallied from 0-2 against Houston, but that series came in a one-off division round during the strike-split season. Cleveland’s immediate challenge is familiar: history gives neither side much of an edge. Among 18 teams that fell behind 0-2 and then won Games 3 and 4, 10 went on to take Game 5, according to MLB.com. Home teams have won 19 of 41 winner-take-all Division Series games.
Cleveland’s series swings back home
The Guardians won 102 games and opened against Chicago with a 4-0 shutout, followed by a 9-8 victory in 13 innings. The White Sox then answered in the Bronx—rather, on their home field—with 1-0 and 7-3 wins, sending the deciding game back to Cleveland. In the current series, Cleveland has responded with consecutive 9-run performances at Chicago: a 9-3 win Wednesday and a 9-5 victory Thursday, powered by a six-run sixth inning.
The franchise has also experienced the other side of this kind of reversal. Cleveland lost 2-0 series leads to Boston in 1999 and the Yankees in 2017. The Oakland Athletics are the only other club to have surrendered a 2-0 lead twice. If Cleveland completes the comeback, it will join the 2001 Yankees and 2015 Blue Jays as the only teams to lose the first two games at home and then win Game 5 in their own park. The 2012 Giants also began with two home losses before finishing the series on the road.
Toronto’s dramatic rally against Texas
The 2015 Blue Jays’ series against Texas turned on a chaotic seventh inning in Game 5. The Rangers had taken both games in Toronto, including a 14-inning Game 2. Toronto won twice in Arlington to force the decisive game back home, where the seventh inning alone lasted 53 minutes.
Texas moved ahead after Russell Martin’s throw toward the mound struck Shin-Soo Choo’s bat, allowing Rougned Odor to score. The ruling prompted a delay as fans threw debris onto the field. In the bottom half, three consecutive Texas errors opened the door for Toronto. José Bautista then hit a three-run homer off Sam Dyson, punctuating it with a bat flip that became one of the postseason’s defining images. Toronto won 6-3.
San Francisco finished its comeback on the road
The 2012 Giants overcame an especially imposing start by Cincinnati. The Reds outscored San Francisco 14-2 in the first two games at AT&T Park. A one-year format gave Cincinnati the final three games at home, but the Giants won all of them.
San Francisco took Game 3 in 10 innings after Scott Rolen bobbled a ground ball, then won Game 4 by an 8-3 score. In Game 5, Buster Posey hit a grand slam off Mat Latos in the fifth inning to give the Giants a 6-0 lead. Cincinnati brought the tying run to the plate in the ninth, but Sergio Romo struck out Rolen to end the game. It was the first time a team had won a best-of-five series by taking three straight road games. The Giants went on to win the World Series.
Boston and New York traded the same reversal
Boston’s 2003 comeback against Oakland marked the Athletics’ second lost 2-0 lead in three years. Oakland took the first two games, including a 5-1 win in Game 2. Back at Fenway Park, Trot Nixon’s two-run homer won Game 3 in the 11th inning, and David Ortiz’s two-run double in the eighth decided Game 4.
In Game 5, Jason Varitek tied the score with a sixth-inning homer off Barry Zito. Manny Ramirez followed with a three-run shot, giving Boston a 4-1 lead behind Pedro Martinez. Oakland narrowed the gap to 4-3 and loaded the bases with three walks in the ninth. Derek Lowe ended the threat by striking out Terrence Long looking.
Two years earlier, the Yankees had reversed a 2-0 deficit against the same Oakland franchise. The three-time defending champions lost the first two games at Yankee Stadium to a 102-win Athletics team, then won Game 3 in Oakland, 1-0. Derek Jeter’s flip to Jorge Posada cut down Jeremy Giambi at home and became one of the most replayed postseason plays.
New York won Game 4 by 9-2 and closed the series at home, 5-3, with help from a David Justice homer and a Mariano Rivera save. Jeter added another memorable play in the eighth, tumbling into the stands to catch a foul pop from Long—the same hitter who would make the final out of Boston’s comeback in 2003. The Yankees became the first team to win a Division Series after losing its opening two games at home.
Earlier comebacks set the standard
Boston’s 1999 rally against Cleveland produced an extreme change in scoring. Cleveland won Game 1 on a Travis Fryman walk-off single and took Game 2 by 11-1. At Fenway Park, the Red Sox scored 32 runs across the next two games, including a 23-7 Game 4 that set the record for runs by one team in a postseason game.
Game 5 was tied 8-8 in the fourth inning when Boston brought in Pedro Martinez, who had left Game 1 with a back injury. Martinez delivered six no-hit innings in relief and struck out eight. Troy O’Leary, already responsible for a grand slam, hit a three-run homer in the seventh as Boston won 12-8. Cleveland fired manager Mike Hargrove after the series.
The first Division Series of the wild-card era gave Seattle a comeback for the ages. The Yankees won the first two games in New York, with the second lasting 15 innings and ending after 1 a.m. Seattle had the next three at the Kingdome under the 1995 format. Randy Johnson won Game 3, and Edgar Martinez drove in seven runs in Game 4, including a go-ahead grand slam in the eighth.
In Game 5, Ken Griffey Jr.’s homer and a bases-loaded walk tied the score in the eighth. Johnson then came out of the bullpen and threw three innings. New York went ahead 5-4 in the 11th, but Seattle answered: Joey Cora bunted for a hit, Griffey singled, and Martinez lined a double to left. Griffey sprinted home from first for a 6-5 win, a moment widely credited with keeping baseball in Seattle.
Cleveland now has one game to add its own chapter. A win would make it the eighth team since 1995 to erase a 0-2 Division Series deficit, while a White Sox victory would make Chicago the eighth team to lose after winning the first two. First pitch at Progressive Field is scheduled for 8 p.m. ET, with Tampa Bay waiting for the winner. History leaves the matchup close; Cleveland’s two recent road wins have made the final game the only fact that matters.