The early 2026-27 season is already testing some familiar assumptions. The New York Rangers have emerged as a surprise contender, while struggling starts in Calgary, Philadelphia and Carolina put pressure on teams built around very different expectations. The sample is small, but the first results are beginning to separate promising adjustments from problems that may be harder to contain.
New York’s defense is setting the tone
The Rangers sit atop the Metropolitan Division after wins over the Utah Mammoth and Tampa Bay Lightning, including a 5-1 result against a Tampa team widely viewed as a potential Eastern Conference powerhouse. They’ve allowed just eight goals, the NHL’s third-best mark so far, with Igor Shesterkin anchoring a defense that has looked composed.
New York has also started to spread its offense around after trading Artemi Panarin. Alexis Lafrenière is showing flashes of the ability that made him the first overall pick, and Mika Zibanejad remains reliable. Gabriel Perreault’s emergence may be the more consequential development: if he can become an elite top-line winger, the Rangers could sustain this early momentum with a broader attack.
Dallas has yet to find a reliable level
The Stars chose continuity this offseason, re-signing Jason Robertson to a one-year deal as they try to make a run. That decision came at the expense of already thinning depth, and the opening results have offered little clarity about whether the bet will pay off.
Dallas handled the Sabres and Sharks, but then lost to the Predators and Blues—teams it would be expected to beat. The key question is whether those defeats reflect early-season rust or the inconsistency that has troubled the Stars over the past few years. For now, their ceiling and floor remain difficult to read.
Early results are reshaping the Eastern picture
Montreal and Philadelphia are already near the bottom of the standings. The Canadiens have surrendered 19 goals in four games, a defensive collapse that has left even productive scoring nights difficult to convert into wins.
Philadelphia’s problem is at the other end: six goals in five games make the Flyers the league’s lowest-scoring team. The hoped-for offensive progress from Trevor Zegras and Matvei Michkov hasn’t arrived yet, and the defense has also looked porous. If both issues persist, the Flyers face a difficult season.
The Rangers are part of a more encouraging group that also includes the Senators, Capitals and Islanders, all of whom have made early progress. Whether they can hold their positions as the season develops is still an open question.
Carolina’s goaltending remains a concern
The defending champions have allowed only 105 shots through five games, yet goaltending has again become a weak point. Brandon Bussi, who took over during the Stanley Cup Final, has posted an .851 save percentage and a 3.24 goals-against average. Backup Pyotr Kotchekov is also below a .900 save percentage.
Carolina has managed to absorb uneven goaltending in recent seasons, but that margin may narrow. Its strong scoring start could help in the short term; it’s harder to count on that continuing if the saves don’t come.
Calgary’s opening skid is historically alarming
The Flames are 0-4 with a minus-17 goal differential, a start that has gone wrong at both ends of the ice. They’re struggling to score, defend and stop shots. The season is young, but the scale of the deficit makes the next stretch especially important.
If the slide continues into November, comparisons with the 1974-75 Washington Capitals will become harder to avoid. That team finished 8-67-5 with a minus-265 differential; Calgary is currently on pace for minus-349. That projection will change quickly if the Flames stabilize, but it captures just how bad the opening has been.
Toronto looks more organized
The Maple Leafs are 2-2-1, but the record doesn’t tell the whole story: they’ve kept games close and looked more cohesive at both ends. Coach Jim Hiller, a debatable hire after his time with the LA Kings, has Toronto playing with greater structure so far.
Gavin McKenna has also produced three points in five games and appears to be growing in confidence. Toronto may still be a couple of years from serious contention, but its early progress offers a clearer foundation to build on. The next test is whether that organization holds as opponents and pressure increase.